| |||||||
| Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism |
| |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Rate Thread |
| | #1 (permalink) | |
| He hath an axe to grynde Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 53
| Cat Kin - novel extract Hi all - Here's a snippet from chapter 2 of my new fantasy novel for kids, 'Cat Kin'. Background to this extract: Tiffany and her parents have just been visiting the hospital where her younger brother Stuart is being treated (he suffers from muscular dystrophy). Comments most welcome. From chapter 2: Quote:
| |
| | |
| | #2 (permalink) |
| Jack of all trades Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 1,138
| Re: Cat Kin - novel extract Hi Green Knight, This is going to be a particularly useless critique so sorry in advance. There may be punctuation issues such as "A proper club." not being a sentence but Chrispenycat is far better at this than me, so I will leave it alone. Other than that, I can't see one single word I would change. Just like your cat poem I absolutely loved it. Kid's ficton is not normally my thing but this novel would be an exception. Entertaining, interesting, excellent. I have been advised not to post too much if you want to get it published, which you definately should. I say this with regret as I would dearly love to read more. |
| | |
| | #3 (permalink) |
| He hath an axe to grynde Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 53
| Re: Cat Kin - novel extract Cheers Jack, glad you like! (It is actually published - self-published - already, as it happens, but thanks for the well-intentioned warning. You can read a bit more in fact (Chaps 1 to 3) on my website if you're so inclined. :-) |
| | |
| | #4 (permalink) |
| resident pedantissimo | Re: Cat Kin - novel extract Actually, I went through it with a fine tooth comb, and didn't find annything which warranted a me intervention. Yes, there are two or three sentences which are not gramatically perfect- shortages of verbs, or even subjects ("No.",as a gramatical sentence might make school teachers cringe- but it contains the entirety of its concept, and adding anything to it, or trying to blend it with the sentences on either side of it, would weaken its message) The relaxed, conversational style carries it forwards, all nescessary punctuation is there, and that same slyle is very simple, well adapted to a younger audience while not condescending- I'd like more cat, but one suspects this will be coming later. Just to prove I'm not going soft:- ‘Sorry, sweetheart. It’s not that we want to get rid of you. But we do have a lot on our plate these days. If we know you’re having fun doing something of your own, we can catch our breath once a week. Do you see?’ ‘You want to get rid of me.’ I'd have put "You do want to get rid of me" to negate the first "it's not that we want to". How's that for a minor modification? But, basically, I didn't post because it didn't need me. |
| | |