| |
|
| |||||||
| Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Rate Thread |
| | #1 (permalink) | |
| Plastic Paddy Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Netherlands
Posts: 2,705
| Lucius (2) Ok, I decided to pick up my Lucius project once more. Here's a revised draft of the first part. I also changed the setting from Sci-fi to Fantasy. Quote:
| |
| | |
| | #2 (permalink) | |||||||||
| KenDodd'sDad'sDog'sDead Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Essex
Posts: 794
| Re: Lucius (2) Ah yes, I remember Lucius the first time around. An intriguing piece this Marky, and it didn't lose any of its fascination this time round either. It does seem to feel more suited to fantasy than sci-fi for some reason, but there are a couple of bits that lend themselves more to sci-fi than fantasy: Quote:
Quote:
Other than those two observations, I think this works much better as a fantasy piece. There are several fascinating ideas in this piece that raise questions in my mind, making me want to see more: Why does the city move and where does it move to? Why is talking about death a taboo subject? Why are only a few people allowed to read? Why does the Empress' daughter seem so vague to Alex, yet very real in another sense? Really interesting concepts these, without obvious answers (apart from maybe the forbidding of reading - danger of a cliche there). A few grammar things: I fear that the "a" key might be stuck on your keyboard. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
| |||||||||
| | |
| | #3 (permalink) |
| He hath an axe to grynde Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Hertfordshire
Posts: 53
| Re: Lucius (2) There is a definite sense of strangeness and wonder about this piece, which is very much in its favour. Very hard to seem original in the area of fantasy worlds (ironically) and this shows definite promise. The present tense style I like, although it needs polish in places; sometimes it can lead a writer into awkward phrases, but nothing a few revisions can't take care of. The use of italic thoughts is perhaps a bit over-done. At first I thought that the hero had some inner companion, like a Pullman-esque daemon, whispering in his ear. Too much inner monologue can be distracting - use it sparely for maximum effect. Another thing to cut back on, perhaps, is letting us know what the character thinks when he's just spoken. Unless it contrasts radically with his uttered words, you don't need to explain again what's on his mind. If he's obviously annoyed, just cut the bit that says he's annoyed. (Always best to show not tell, anyway). Definitely an intriguing opening. Keep going! |
| | |
| | #4 (permalink) | |||
| Plastic Paddy Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Netherlands
Posts: 2,705
| Re: Lucius (2) Thank you both for your time to have a look at this piece. Quote:
Maybe you’re right, though I don’t see why this is unrealistic. You can have large books in any given time, can’t you? Quote:
I used the word ‘alien’ as strange. Not an alien creature. But to not confuse the reader, I’ll change it. I won’t answer the questions you raise, because those questions are pretty much the story… The last one isn’t too hard to answer though, because I thought I made it pretty obvious. Why does the Empress' daughter seem so vague to Alex, yet very real in another sense? Well, because Alex is totally in love with her, of course. If that wasn’t too clear, I must work on that. Thank you for pointing out the grammar-y things. Quote:
| |||
| | |
| | #5 (permalink) | |
| KenDodd'sDad'sDog'sDead Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Essex
Posts: 794
| Re: Lucius (2) Quote:
![]() | |
| | |
| | #6 (permalink) |
| Reliably Inconsistent... Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Northamptonshire
Posts: 77
| Re: Lucius (2) Really good read. I like the whole inner monologue bits although am wondering how much of this is willing thought and how much is verging on schizophrenia? The conversation with himself almost seems like the 'other' voice has its own agenda, perhaps I'm off the mark. Agree with Green Knight, used slightly on the generous side which again leads me to think this 'voice' is not so controlled by Alex. As for the questions posed, I am intrigued with the Daharir pulling the city along. At first I thought this could be because the earth itself was dangerous to people, but then the mention of them resting at times in the stables suggested otherwise, unless these Daharir choose to rest in an organised way themselves... oh the questions! The feelings between Alex and Arnay are very hard to get down properly and this might need to be made more obvious although in principle it is good. At the moment I read it as though he's verging on nervousness and awe rather than dumbstruck love... Anyway... as you can probably see, I'm new to this so apologies if my comments aren't great. A good piece which I enjoyed. |
| | |
| | #7 (permalink) |
| Plastic Paddy Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Netherlands
Posts: 2,705
| Re: Lucius (2) Not at all, Sparker. All comments are apreciated. Your observation about he's nervous more than in love is quite true. Maybe it's not too clear, by Amay is going to be the leader of the band, and Alex is just a bit of an average Joe. This is love that can't ever happen, so it makes perfect sense he's nervous as hell... |
| | |
|
| About | Link To Us | For Writers | For Publishers | Privacy | Terms of Use | Copyright | Press | XML/RSS | Contact Us © Copyright Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles 2003-2008 |