Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums - View Single Post

HBP · 30th July 2007, 04:53 AM

Well i thought the movie was good enough to watch. Not the best adaptation of the books. I think the director was mainly concentrating on how to please the audience rather than being faithful to the book. It lacked details that i thought was relevant to the plot (the locket) and expounded on insignificant trivial matters (like harry and cho's relationship). All in all it is of my opinion that it didn't do as bad as Chris Columbus word for word portrayal and Alfonso Cuaron's catastrophe. It fell at GOF feet though.

Well I don't think JK would be on the set every once in a while and let them ruin the book that she has worked so hard on.

30th July 2007, 04:53 AM	#66 (permalink)
HBP U've guessed it..i'm good Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Florida Posts: 117	Re: OOTP movie (maybe spoilers) Well i thought the movie was good enough to watch. Not the best adaptation of the books. I think the director was mainly concentrating on how to please the audience rather than being faithful to the book. It lacked details that i thought was relevant to the plot (the locket) and expounded on insignificant trivial matters (like harry and cho's relationship). All in all it is of my opinion that it didn't do as bad as Chris Columbus word for word portrayal and Alfonso Cuaron's catastrophe. It fell at GOF feet though. Well I don't think JK would be on the set every once in a while and let them ruin the book that she has worked so hard on.