View Single Post
Old 22nd July 2007, 01:29 AM   #24 (permalink)
Balinor
Why thank ye good sirs
 
Balinor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 103
Re: has anyone else finished yet?

Quote:
Originally Posted by BrightFeather View Post
yeah, it didnt give you enough to get your teeth into!

The order of the phoenix was 956 pages much better

Too right. I got it at about half twelve last. Read till 4 am ish then fel asleep. Woke up just before eleven and finished at 3.

SPOILERS
The final battle in Hogwarts should have been much longer. and the start with hte sesarch for the Horcrux needed to have more dialogue and description. I thought the search was over too quickly and there were places where it didn't describe what they did for weeks. 1000+ pages would have been my dream with
-More dialogue
-Longer description of the battles
-An extended search for the Horcruxes

Havingsaid that I thought the part about Snape with the pensice was very well done. gave a good insight into the character and confirmed that he was (although not fully) good.

I also would have liked t have read more about what happened to the deatheaters (especially Lucius) when Voldy got peeved witht them.
Balinor is offline   Reply With Quote