Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums - View Single Post - Book 7

Balinor · 21st July 2007, 04:34 PM

Well, I thought the book was good on the wohole although (spoiler) I did miss the usual hogwarts setting for the most of it. The part where they went back and had the battle with the teachers I thought was ablosutely brilliant. Althought I think it could have done with including more about the other creatures (like the giants and thestrals etc) that were present.

In regards to the 3 questions you posted.

1) Don't know but would be nice to get an answre

2) I expect so. There seemed to be something there and (spoiler)the others got together as I expected

3) Well (spoilers) they said it was handed down from father to son so I assume that James was given it by his dad. I didn't see anything to suggest
otherwise

Although I thought the book was great there was some things I was a bit disappointed with .two things stand out at the moment for me - (spoilers)

1) Dumbledore seeing himself as a power hungry maniac was a bit disappointing. I expected more

2) Supposedly 2 main characters die (I assume this refers to Dobby and Fred). I think that she should have killed off either Harry, Ron or Hermionie. In my eyes Fred wasn't involved enough to be counted as a main character and dobby hadn't been involved enough. Mad-eye, Tonks and Lupin were (IMO) at least as important.

21st July 2007, 04:34 PM	#2 (permalink)
Balinor Why thank ye good sirs Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 103	Re: Book 7 - Unanswered Questions (SPOILERS likely) Well, I thought the book was good on the wohole although (spoiler) I did miss the usual hogwarts setting for the most of it. The part where they went back and had the battle with the teachers I thought was ablosutely brilliant. Althought I think it could have done with including more about the other creatures (like the giants and thestrals etc) that were present. In regards to the 3 questions you posted. 1) Don't know but would be nice to get an answre 2) I expect so. There seemed to be something there and (spoiler)the others got together as I expected 3) Well (spoilers) they said it was handed down from father to son so I assume that James was given it by his dad. I didn't see anything to suggest otherwise Although I thought the book was great there was some things I was a bit disappointed with .two things stand out at the moment for me - (spoilers) 1) Dumbledore seeing himself as a power hungry maniac was a bit disappointing. I expected more 2) Supposedly 2 main characters die (I assume this refers to Dobby and Fred). I think that she should have killed off either Harry, Ron or Hermionie. In my eyes Fred wasn't involved enough to be counted as a main character and dobby hadn't been involved enough. Mad-eye, Tonks and Lupin were (IMO) at least as important.