Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums - View Single Post - Guesses for Book 7 (Assume **spoilers** for all previous 6 books!!)

Crazihors · 12th June 2007, 02:58 PM

I have some theories: first off, it's Dumbledore's fault James and Lily died, reasons for this include:
1. the continually shifting blame for the death of Harry's parents: PS/SS it's simply Voldemort, PoA it shifts twice from Sirius to Wormtail (am I the only one who refuses to call him Peter? He doesn't deserve it), then in OotP it becomes some sort of spy, and in HBP it transforms again into Snape (who is not good or evil, he's just a more gutsy version of Wormtail.
2. He is forver mentioning his 'old man's mistakes' in OotP and HBP
3. why else is Dumbledore so concerned about Harry's safety? JKR said they aren't related, so it's probably guilt.
4. when they're getting the 'horcrux', Dumbledore drinks the potion and starts screaming 'it's my fault, it's all my fault, kill me!' or something to that effect.

12th June 2007, 02:58 PM	#73 (permalink)
Crazihors Tenebris Noctis Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 77	Re: Guesses for Book 7 (Assume spoilers for all previous 6 books!!) I have some theories: first off, it's Dumbledore's fault James and Lily died, reasons for this include: 1. the continually shifting blame for the death of Harry's parents: PS/SS it's simply Voldemort, PoA it shifts twice from Sirius to Wormtail (am I the only one who refuses to call him Peter? He doesn't deserve it), then in OotP it becomes some sort of spy, and in HBP it transforms again into Snape (who is not good or evil, he's just a more gutsy version of Wormtail. 2. He is forver mentioning his 'old man's mistakes' in OotP and HBP 3. why else is Dumbledore so concerned about Harry's safety? JKR said they aren't related, so it's probably guilt. 4. when they're getting the 'horcrux', Dumbledore drinks the potion and starts screaming 'it's my fault, it's all my fault, kill me!' or something to that effect.