Buffy every time.
Yeah I totally had a *crush* on her, I know everyone says Evil Willow, and I get it, but I heart Buffy!! Plus Oz and Spike were the best guys, Angel was a bit blah. Oh and Giles singing Wish I could stay in OMWF, *sigh*. Plus the Mustard guy,(OMWF) just because I loved his enthusiasm, it won me over.