[Winter Lord]

Originally Posted by Kanazaka

Sorry to revive a dead thread, but yeah, you were right about Amy (okay, Amy's been on my mind a lot lately). Truthfully, I wish that Amy would have joined the Trio to become a quartet. Here's my scenario for how that would have happened. Amy shows up at Willow's door and Willow slams the door in her face when Amy asks how she liked her dose of black magic (I'm pretty sure that was what happened, since it's been a long time since I've seen that episode). Angry, Amy seeks out the Trio; we don't truly know whether or not Amy knew about the Trio before Warren's death, but I'm guessing she did. She orders the Trio to distract Buffy and the gang while she hunts down Tara and kills her. Amy finds Tara and they fight, but because Amy is much stronger, she kills Tara. Meanwhile, Willow has been searching for Tara, and locates her just as Amy kills her. Willow becomes "Wicked Willow" and fights and kills Amy, then seeks out the Trio (Amy tells Willow that they distracted her while she sought out Tara). From this point on, the end of Season Six progresses as normal (Willow kills Warren, etc.). This alternate plotline would have required some rejiggering of Season Six's episodes, but I think it would have made a much better conclusion to the Willow/Amy storyline.

She wasn't Wicked Willow, she was Darth Rosenburg.