Go Back   Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums > Books and Writing > Aspiring Writers > Critiques

Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism. YOU MUST HAVE A POST COUNT OF 30 TO POST A PIECE TO BE CRITIQUED.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old 6th October 2005, 06:51 PM   #1 (permalink)
Starship Manufacturer
 
dreamwalker's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Greater London
Posts: 332
Lines of Green... Continued

This is in the second chapter, a few moments on from the start. Jadra's in an interview speaking to the ancorlady Abryal and we join the story in the middle of a flash back from jadra's childhood.
All critts welcomed and sincerly appricated. most of all, if you felt indifferent about the story, I really want you to tell me why.
Thanks

From Lines Green and Black Chapter 2 (Year one)

After class, Jadra walked out onto the corridor with a number of glass cards tucked between her arm and chest. She was alone although dozens of children lined the walls, some of them leaving the class room, others just standing there. Some of the children broke conversation and just starred. Her self esteem was already badly fried. Her Nerves where as frail as her hair, but she just wanted to get through it, past the children and onto the foyer. She was tripped. She stumbled a little but remained on her feet. She heard giggles but didn’t look around, just down, and continued to walk trying only to get to the corridors end. She was tripped again, more aggressively this time and this time she lost her footing and crashed face first into the ground. There was blatant laughter by everyone around her. She was in pain, with not just the humiliation but one of the glass pads cracked and had sliced her arm and hand. A vicious glare erupted on her face. She knew exactly who it was as she began to pick her self up. The boy was laughing hysterically, arms crossed and facing away from her. She left a couple of the pads in her hand, the ones which didn’t hurt. She held them as she and turned around, not looking up at the person she knew had tripped her until she swung with the full force of her right hand. A swift back hand, the hand with the pads extended outward in a perfect leftwards and upwards ark. The pad and his face connected and the full shock of the blow was felt by everyone near him. It was so sudden, and violent, the boy never saw it coming, never heard the appalling sharp, muted sound of layered plastic-coated glass shattering against human cheek bone. The sound was heard by everyone there except the boy as he was already unconscious and on his way to the floor. No one expected it; no one even really saw the movement, it was so fast. Blood dripped down from Jadra’s cut wrist and onto the shattered pads. It was a few brief moments before the crowd of children slowly made there way to the boy who was knocked out cold. They whispered and talked amongst themselves. Jadra was numb, the anger and pain of before was completely cancelled out by this act. She dropped the pads and starred at the result of her wrath. Teachers later came telling the children to get back and make room.

‘Jadra smacking him silly Sir, she’s pawned him with her pad.’ One of the children professed. Jadra was silent as the hot fuss grew around them.

‘Get back will you?’ One of the teachers said.

Jadra was sitting on chairs out on a passage with school boards and glass displays. She had tears running down her cheeks but wasn’t actively crying. Her hand was bandaged from hand to elbow with a moist grey strap material. She could barely move her fingers.

‘Mom will get here. She’ll understand and set things straight.’ She was there for a very long time. For her it felt like forever as for how ever long it really was, it was too long to be left alone with those kinds of thoughts. A woman approached Jadra; Jadra looked up at her as she approached. Jadra was miftly frightened by the look on the woman’s face as she came to slowly kneel in front of her.



‘I’m guessing that’s how you learnt your parents where assassinated?’ Abryal said, fully engrossed by the story so far yet in keeping of the current tone.

‘That’s right. You know how bad things normally happen all at once? And the very last thing or the very worst thing puts it all into perspective. That was that day.’ There was silence for a few moments. Jadra was sad but not bitter; she turned and looked up at Abryal who, to her seemed closer to her for listening to what she just said. ‘From when I woke up I’ll never forget that day.’ Jadra looked up and caught something in Abryal’s gaze she didn’t like. ‘I

‘I don’t want your pity, or your sorrow, or your empathy. My life isn’t a sob story or a sad movie.’ Jadra said aggressively as if insulted with Abryal’s the brief show of warmness

‘I’m, I understand, I apologise. Please, go on.’


If any one wants to read the whole story so far i'll upload an html version on request!
dreamwalker is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 6th October 2005, 08:12 PM   #2 (permalink)
KenDodd'sDad'sDog'sDead
 
Paradox 99's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Essex
Posts: 838
Re: Lines of Green... Continued

Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
Some of the children broke conversation and just starred.
Oops.

Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
Her Nerves where as frail as her hair

Not sure how hair can be frail, but it does paint the picture for me.

Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
She was tripped. She stumbled a little but remained on her feet. She heard giggles but didn’t look around, just down, and continued to walk trying only to get to the corridors end...
I really like this part. There's something in the way you constructed that sentence that really made me sympathise with Jadra.

Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
She held them as she and turned around
I think a word was missed after the "she"?



Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
She dropped the pads and starred at the result of her wrath.
Oops. Starred again. Should be "stared".


Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
Teachers later came telling the children to get back and make room.
Sounds a bit odd and detached. Maybe just change it to "came later"?


Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamwalker
If any one wants to read the whole story so far i'll upload an html version on request!
Yep, count me in. I like your story so far. You've done a great job of making Jadra a really interesting character. I've only a vague idea of plot, but Jadra is intriguing enough for me to want to know more. I'd love to read more.
Paradox 99 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 6th October 2005, 08:21 PM   #3 (permalink)
Smarter Than I Look
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 378
Blog Entries: 8
Re: Lines of Green... Continued

This is some strong writing--an effective scene and characterization. I've just got a couple of picky things...

On the sentence,

Her Nerves where as frail as her hair, (great description, by the way)

nerves should not be capitalized, that's just typo;

on the third paragraph from the end, you have what looks like a hanging "I" at the end of the second sentence,

Jadra looked up and caught something in Abryal’s gaze she didn’t like. ‘I

I think that's another typo, and it would read better if that was deleted, and the writing simply went to the next paragraph,

‘I don’t want your pity, or your sorrow, or your empathy....

I'm also curious as to what the adjective "miftly" means,

Jadra was miftly frightened by the look on the woman’s face...

If that's a British slang word that I'm not familiar, then I'd say it's okay. My preference would be to either drop the adjective and simply say,

Jadra was frightened by the look...

but that's just me. If miftly is accepted slang and it works for you, then it doesn't bother me as much.

That's all for the picky stuff. Again, this is effective writing and characterization. I'd like to see you post more of it. I probably don't have time to read the entire work, but a page or two every day or so wouldn't be hard to keep up with.

Hope this was helpful. All for the moment Terry.

P.S. One other question on reflection--just what is in those glass cases or cards that she's carrying?
terryweide is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 6th October 2005, 09:12 PM   #4 (permalink)
Starship Manufacturer
 
dreamwalker's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Greater London
Posts: 332
Re: Lines of Green... Continued

Heh, I need to get me an editor! I've probably read and re-read the section but I seem to miss out mistakes, probably because I only read want I want to read.

I've gone and made the corrections, and i've also writen a little extra. Origanaly, jadra was a pretty sterotypical charater, same old motivations etc, but since writing she's taken on her own charater, it kinda feels like I have no control over it.
As for your questions...

Her hair was in very bad codition, infact it was the reason for the talk and the teasing - thats apparent in the full story.

Miftly comes from miffed, which is a kind of quiet astonishment or bemusement.
Its probably a made up word, but its there to describe the expression that came with the being frighted, without knowing why.
The kind of the look you'd have when you knew someone was going to give you very bad news. but still I didn't want to telegraph what Abryal says next, so as to make it more of a shock.

The class cards where computers - I try describe stuff, instead of telling people what they actually are or what there function is, removes obvious images people have from experiance, to allow for this to be as far in the future as it actually is.

many thanks for your comments, crits, and interest, i'll be putting up a full version somewhere soon.
dreamwalker is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:44 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.