View Single Post
Old 27th March 2005, 11:24 PM   #7 (permalink)
GOLLUM
Moderator
 
GOLLUM's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 5,229
Re: Ursula Le Guin's best?

Quote:
Originally Posted by knivesout
What would you say is Ursula Le Guin's best novel and short story in her long and reasonably prolific career?

I incline more towards sf, so even though the Earthsea books are a truly excellent read, I'd have to choose my favourite from her sf works.

While there are many contenders, my personal favourite here is The Lathe of Heaven. It's a book about a man in a near future dystopian earth who realises that he can re-shape reality through his dreams. Terrified, he attempts to squash this ability by taking drugs that keep him from dreaming. Instead, he is sent to a psychiatrist for treatment for drugh abuse. The psychiatrist learns of hius powers, and starts using them to reshape the world into a better sate - or so he thinks. Instead, each of his changes, while dealing with real-life problems have often terrifying unexcpected consequences. The dreamer attempts to run away from the docotr, is re-captured, and watches helpless as this monomaniac creates one false utopia after another. The dreamer finally takes matters back into his own hands ands re-establishes a non-ideal (but immensely changed) status quo with the aid of aliens who were created by one of his dream-revisions.

It is mildly Philip K Dick-ian in its subversion of surface reality, but it also deals with LeGUin's recurring theme of the perils of Utopia-building.

Other notable novels are The Disposessed, the Word for World is Forest and The Left Hand of Darkness - each one is a deserved classic, but Lathe is just my personal favourite.

I think the best short story LeGuin has ever written is the Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas, a tale that responds to the classic dillema, 'would you be willing to let one person live in total misery so that millions could have a good life?' with a passionate and resounding 'NO!'.

WHat about you? What do you think are LeGuin's best works, and why?

Here is her bibliography: http://www.ursulakleguin.com/Bibliography-Plain.html
Hi Knivesout and everyone else here,

Have you checked out my new thread that will feature a "classic" fantasy author/week titled Classic Fantasy Pre 1980s in the Books & Literature Forum yet?? Please stop by and post a comment if possible as Ursula will be one of the authors featured, although probably not in huge detail as she appears in this Author forum already. Everyone, maybe you could suggest a great fantasy author or two I've missed based on the crtieria I have posted there?

Anyway Ursula K. LeGuin holds a special memory for me because her original Earthsea trilogy was I thnk the first fantasy books I ever read way back in the mid '70s and got me on the path to the fantasy series ever since!! Therefore I would have to vote for The Earthsea series and for the Sci Fi stable The Left Hand Of Darkness as her two greatest works.

Bye for now.
GOLLUM is offline   Reply With Quote