Strong Female Characters*

[allmywires]

*kudos to anyone who gets the Kate Beaton reference.

I come with this article from io9.com: http://io9.com/5912366/why-i-write-s...ale-characters

Somewhat of a long read, but worthwhile. A male author talking about his characters, specifically, his Strong Female Characters, and how people often comment upon it. To quote: 'Why do [male authors] default to a shorthand, lazy equation, where strong equals b*tch?'

So my real question to you is: when you're writing your female characters, do you take special consideration of them because of their gender? Do you find it easier to write men or women, and is that because you identify more with your own gender? DO you avoid the damsel in distress trope, or do you embrace its value to the story?

And do you default to 'strong = b*tch', whether consciously or unconsciously?

[springs]

I hope anyone having read mine would say that the central female character is neither a bitch, nor weak. In fact, she's turning into the most interesting character in the books and more and more scenes are shifting to her point of view. But, it's not about her being a female, just that its the way she is. I don't see the whole distinction, really, people are who they are. My male protagonist is very far from the chisel chinned hero cliche, so, too, my female protagonist (see, she's got herself elevated to protagonist now) is no cliched bitch.

I am slowly realising that the lack of cliche may make it less than universally popular, but hey ho, noone I've ever known is actually so rounded they are cliched, not in real life. *raises champage supernova toast to AMW for an interesting post*

[HoopyFrood]

Just popping in to say I have a great deal of respect for Greg Rucka, he helped shaped my favourite comic book character and generally did a fantastic job in an industry that does have a hell of a lot of problems when it comes to women (the characters and the readers alike). Plus he can spin a damn good storyline.

(Also, as to Kate Beaton -- I have both my boobs and butt in the frame, I am a Strong Female Character!)


Answer to the question, I can't say I have ever written gender, not consciously, anyway (but there's a whole kettle of fish). I never think "well, here's a guy, so he'd..." I've had probably the typical, driven, stoic police officer type, but that was in a story where the 'villain' was a mid-twenties male who was utterly dependent on his supercomputer companion, probably wouldn't say boo to a goose and tended to get rather hysterical.

My women probably default to a little bit kick-ass and headstrong, because I often write in first person and there's no doubt a lot of wishful personality channelling

Mind you, that was before I got heavily into poststructuralism, so I'd probably subvert gender, sex and sexuality all over the place now. Trans*, queer, pansexual, cis, I'd like to write every kind I can.

[Mouse]

I love men. Men are the best. That is all.

[Venusian Broon]

Yes great questions Allmywires,

I think there could be quite a few reasons where strong=bitch arises.

It could be that the male writer has an incomplete understanding of the opposite sex, so has to fall back to torn and worn out cliches.

Perhaps he lacks the imagination to do anything other than a hard-boiled masculine world and hence the only strong role that a successful woman can attain success in, he thinks, has to be a bitch.

Or perhaps, he's having a lot of fun writing a flawed evil bitch. Sure it's a cliche but she gets great lines! Oh and probably some latent sexual submissiveness

---

When it comes to me I'd like to think that I always approach the character as a person first and then 'complicate' him/her/it with gender - of whatever sort - after the flaws and wrinkles are in. At least I hope I do.

Definitely try my hardest to avoid such things as the damsel in distress or the hooker with the heart of gold etc...

This is sort of an issue in my current WiP, because I've deliberately rearranged and changed the gender heirarchy and politics - but at least that means that I sit down hard and think how all the characters should behave in the different roles that this society brings up, and hence I'm hoping I leave cliches unused.

On top of this, at the end of the day, they are still biologically women and men. And the third grouping I invented

[Mouse]

Ok serious now. I do prefer writing men. I have no idea why - like I've said in other threads where this has come up, I guess men just interest me more.

I do love writing bitches though. I have one character who's a stuck up, sex-mad, bisexual bitch who gets off on torture. She also loves horses and yoga - she teaches kids to ride and hand-reared a baby bunny she rescued from an animal testing place. She self harms. She's not a fighter, but she'd claw out someone's eyes if they looked at her the wrong way.

[allmywires]

Originally Posted by springs1971

*raises champage supernova toast to AMW for an interesting post*

*Chinks glass, puts on a bit of Oasis*

Originally Posted by HoopyFrood

(Also, as to Kate Beaton -- I have both my boobs and butt in the frame, I am a Strong Female Character!)

I love Kate Beaton! I'm sad she doesn't update Hark! A Vagrant very much any more.

You see, I have a problem with my female characters. Like Mouse, I really like writing men. But only men of a certain type: I enjoy exploiting the pressures society put on men, how they think they should behave, and how this affects them and how they really feel. I don't write them as crybabies, but I give them ~emotions~. Often a lot more than their female counterparts.

I worry my females come off as bitchy, one-dimensional, harsh and cold. (Just to be clear, I'm a female too, so I'm having the reverse problem of what I posted about). I hate weak females, so I always try to make mine strong: to do what I would do if I were as hypothetically smart or brave or savvy as they are. I just can't seem to distinguish the line between 'smart, sassy and confident' and 'total psycho bitch' (I did not realise that word wasn't censored on here! )

You see, I can write smart and sassy men, and cold and calculating women...but I can't switch them up.

[Venusian Broon]

Ok just to see where you are in relation to my headspace.

(Perhaps not a good example for you youngsters, but for those that watched 90s telly...)

Agent Scully from the X-files. Strong or Weak? Bitch or not-Bitch?

[Sapheron]

In my opinion, I've never had too much trouble with gender. One is pretty similar to the other from my point of view. At least, in terms of writing from their point of view, anyway. Perhaps thats my subconscious trying to tell me things. Perhaps I'm deluded, and my female characters are terrible. I guess we'll never really know...

[Glitch]

I don't know if I'm good at writing women, men or neither! But I write characters with the intention of growing them in some way.

Strong doesn't equal bitch. If a man has to back down and defer to a strong woman he might call her a bitch; but that's his viewpoint and not necessarily how you would write her

Originally Posted by allmywires

You see, I can write smart and sassy men, and cold and calculating women...but I can't switch them up.

Have you tried writing gender neutral? Write a bio for your character; and then work out based on their past experiences how would they react to your new situations.

Originally Posted by Mouse

I have one character who's a stuck up, sex-mad, bisexual bitch who gets off on torture....she'd claw out someone's eyes if they looked at her the wrong way.

Note to self. Be careful critiquing Mouse's work - Aren't all characters a reflection of the author?

[Myra]

In my opinion, 'Never have a man do a woman's job' Just kidding!

In a lot of books I have read, even the damsel in distress is a jaguar underneath waiting to be unleashed and she saves the men a few times (Take the film 'Your Highness'; it may be a comedy and completely mental, but it has a strong female character). Then there are those females that are written as proper 'Oh no...whatever shall I do? Where's my knight in shining armour?'

I reckon females should be given more credit. We have nails (in some cases) and b***h fights our our speciality

Then again I have never really been all that good at writing men, but when I do I try to make them just as good as female characters.

For example I have two main protagonists in my story, one male and one female and they are the leading roles. The female has her Damsel in Distress moments, but my male has his Dude in Distress moments too to balance it out, but they both have a major role each with their own strengths and weaknesses

If I was to choose the easiest to write though I would probably say women because I am one and so I can understand how our minds work...

[Galacticdefender]

Princess Leia from Star Wars is a great example of a strong female character, though I'm not sure if she doesn't fall into the B*tch category every once in a while.

[Warren_Paul]

Originally Posted by Galacticdefender

Princess Leia from Star Wars is a great example of a strong female character, though I'm not sure if she doesn't fall into the B*tch category every once in a while.

Most of the time no, but here is the thing, everyone whether male of female falls into that category every once and awhile. There are things that rub us up the wrong way and we go from being nice, to being aggressive about it. Being bitchy isn't how we'd normally act, but every now and then we do - it's normal.

Sometimes bitchy is just the right way to act in certain situations.

[TheDustyZebra]

Most of my characters have always been men (hmm, that sounds like some of them used to be, but aren't anymore, which isn't the case). I suppose it's probably because I really don't relate to women. I don't do "woman things", I was raised as a tomboy with three older brothers, and I just don't think in "woman".

My WIP has three MC, two boys and a girl, and the girl is the toughest of the bunch. She takes her brother down and sits on his head, shoots lions, and generally takes charge.

[allmywires]

Originally Posted by Venusian Broon

Ok just to see where you are in relation to my headspace.

(Perhaps not a good example for you youngsters, but for those that watched 90s telly...)

Agent Scully from the X-files. Strong or Weak? Bitch or not-Bitch?

Showing my age here VB, since I was born in the 90s (closer to the 80s than the 00s though!).

I can think of a strong female character that I think was executed very well and didn't fall into strong=bitch, and that is Sarah Lund from the Danish TV series Forbrydelsen (the Killing, not the dreadful US remake). She was sometimes cold, but she was dedicated to her job: not to the detriment of her personal life (at least in the beginning). It didn't dissolve into a love story. It was about her and the case.

Maybe that's the problem: we're more tempted to write love stories based around female characters because they are traditional sex objects. (Though I feel the tides are starting to turn on that!)