Go Back   Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums > Books and Writing > Aspiring Writers > Critiques

Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism. YOU MUST HAVE A POST COUNT OF 30 TO POST A PIECE TO BE CRITIQUED.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old 1st March 2012, 03:40 PM   #1 (permalink)
Universe Builder
 
Flugel Meister's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Germany
Posts: 125
The Survivor - sci-fi (Chapter 2) Part 1

First of all I want to thank everyone who helped out with Chapter 1, it was very much appreciated and extremely helpful. The feedback allowed me to see certain elements of the first chapter in a more objective light.

In the first chapter, Liam (the protagonist) was on the Edinburgh Airport shuttle bus to the city centre, heading for his hotel. But Liam's usually routine business plans were thrown into disarray when an unusual and unexpected event occurs -- producing a wall of fire and several violent tremors. Liam, if you remember, was knocked unconscious in the process.

Chapter Two

Emergence


The air was hot – stifling, in fact – when I woke, laden with dirt and dust and the strong stench of something awful. I was unsure at first as to where I was or what had happened.

The bus! I realised. And Edinburgh.

The small shuttle bus – that had taken both me and the few other passengers that had boarded it to the city centre – or what was left of it, was seemingly bathed in darkness. My somewhat sluggish memory was then quickly and violently kicked into gear as I tried to move and my right hand touched the stitched-leather carrying handle of my suitcase. The sights and sounds of the Scottish capital shot sharply into my mind and the dazzling display of light that had preceded the alarming tremors invited a barely subdued sense of panic back into the pit of my stomach.

After several unnerving minutes had passed, I mustered the strength courage to move. My attempts were slow at first. In the blackness I could feel pieces of twisted metal protruding from everywhere and I came to the conclusion that this small and incredibly uncomfortable luggage compartment had ultimately saved me from being impaled by any number of objects: handrails, glass windows, or from being crushed like an insect in the wreck.
In the darkness there was one thing that gave me hope, a small pinprick of light that shone like a heavenly beacon upon a section of the floor. As my eyes adjusted, I began to make out other details. There were more suitcases in the aisle. Some had their contents spilling out like the regurgitated effects of a laundrette while others remained firmly closed. Shattered glass glittered on a nearby seat and there was grit and dirt everywhere.

I looked towards the front of the bus and was shocked to see another pair of eyes staring back at me. They were blank and empty and clearly devoid of life. Below them was the barely recognisable sight of a uniform. It was the bus driver.

‘Help,’ I whimpered. ‘Can anyone hear me?’

Only the steady groan of twisted metal and falling dust provided a reply.

After a heavy sigh I pulled myself from the luggage compartment, hitting my head on the way out, just as I’d done when I fell in. My headache intensified, but I maintained my footing as I clambered out into the aisle.

I looked up at the thin beam of light and yet again found myself gripped by the familiar compulsion to explore. My curiosity had returned. I carefully made my way to the rear of the bus, picking my way through the wreckage, hoping to find a fellow survivor but those I found were clearly dead. The young male passenger that had been thrown and knocked unconscious earlier had then been impaled by a sheet of twisted metal. There was no way to tell if it was part of the bus or just some other piece of debris, thrown violently in our direction. Either way, I doubted the man had any chance anyway. He had been unconscious at the time and then thrown around the interior of the bus like a ragdoll as it rolled. And it showed. His body was contorted in positions that defied the dexterity of any skeleton.

The other passengers were no better off. And even in the low light, I could tell there was a lot of blood – all of it dry, of course.

With my hopes of company dashed, I made my way back towards the luggage area and the pinprick of light.

I needed out.

I stood on the nearby seat that was covered in glass and reached up. The ceiling of the bus was lower than before, crumpled and crushed, no doubt, by falling bricks and boulders. My hand touched the light. I savoured the moment before reaching further and eventually pulling myself up, using the seat to extend my reach. I moved cautiously at first, clearing aside what I could until the dread-filled pit of my stomach demanded otherwise – it demanded a speedy escape. Then, I clawed and clambered through dirt, rubble and something else, something stale and sickly. More and more pinpricks of light stabbed at my vision and I could feel blood on my hands, knees and face as I dug my way out. Until, at last, I emerged, and was immediately greeted by something that I did not expect, daylight.

After being dazzled by sunlight, my vision cleared, only to reveal a sight that made me regret my escape. Around me lay a scarred and battered landscape, a scene of complete desolation. Almost every building had been razed to the ground; burnt and mangled cars littered what was once a proud and popular city and everything was still and silent. But despite the destruction around me, there were no raging infernos sweeping the landscape. No other movement or light, only a partially-clouded sun in the distance.

As I looked upon the broken Earth before me, I realised – with disgust – at what had become both my tomb and my shelter. I had, of course, been buried among the rubble and the remains of a twisted and battered bus, which in itself had fallen victim to the sheer brute force of the shockwave that had forced it from the road, onto the wide path and into the remains of a nearby building. Slabs of concrete and masonry had inevitably fallen on top, crumpling the roof of the bus and crushing or pinning those unfortunate enough to be caught underneath. But it was the topsoil of that tomb that revealed to me the full extent of the destruction that had taken place here. The dead were everywhere. The unusual stench that had filled my nostrils earlier was from a sea of bodies that were laid out, as though on display, like a collection of felled trees. Blood, puss, bile and the stink of decay filled the air and covered the ground.

My stomach immediately tried to surrender its contents but there was nothing to give. I was confused, weary, and half-mad it seemed with thirst. I had no idea how long I had been unconscious in the bus or, more importantly, if I was the only survivor. I pushed those thoughts to the back of my mind and looked upon the broken city before me.

In my destroyed surroundings, with little hope or optimism of my future, the one thing that I noticed about this dead world was – indeed – the lack of life, not just human life but everything. There were no birds, rats, dogs or insects. There was no swarm of flies or even a single maggot to feast upon the countless dead that lay at my feet. There was nothing, only stillness and silence.

More to come...

Again, any and all help is appreciated.
Flugel Meister is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 1st March 2012, 05:23 PM   #2 (permalink)
Senile Member
 
Bowler1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Greater London
Posts: 1,570
Re: The Survivor - sci-fi (Chapter 2) Part 1

The air was hot – stifling, in fact – when I woke, laden with dirt and dust and the strong stench of something awful. I was unsure at first as to where I was or what had happened.
Good opening line.

The bus! I realised. And Edinburgh.

The small shuttle bus – that had taken both me and the few other passengers that had boarded it to the city centre – or what was left of it, was seemingly bathed in darkness. My somewhat sluggish memory was then quickly and violently kicked into gear as I tried to move and my right hand touched the stitched-leather carrying handle of my suitcase. You mention the suitcase but then it has no part in the storyline, so why mention it? The sights and sounds of the Scottish capital shot sharply into my mind and the dazzling display of light that had preceded the alarming tremors invited a barely subdued sense of panic back into the pit of my stomach. I’m not sure what this last line means.

After several unnerving minutes had passed, I mustered the strength and the courage to move. My attempts were slow at first. In the blackness I could feel pieces of twisted metal protruding from everywhere comma maybe? and I came to the conclusion that this small and incredibly uncomfortable luggage compartment had ultimately saved me from being impaled by any number of objects: handrails, glass windows, or from being crushed like an insect in the wreck.
In the darkness there was one thing that gave me hope, a small pinprick of light that shone like a heavenly beacon upon a section of the floor. As my eyes adjusted, I began to make out other details. There were more suitcases in the aisle. Some had their contents spilling out like the regurgitated effects of a laundrette while others remained firmly closed. Shattered glass glittered on a nearby seat and there was grit and dirt everywhere.
Less is more sometimes, shorter I think has more punch, but as this is the introduction so some info is needed. So here, the wall of info does not feel too bad, later is more of a problem.

I looked towards the front of the bus and was shocked to see another pair of eyes staring back at me. They were blank and empty and clearly devoid of life. Below them was the barely recognisable sight of a uniform. It was the bus driver.

‘Help,’ I whimpered. ‘Can anyone hear me?’
In pain, what, is he ok, etc?

Only the steady groan of twisted metal and falling dust provided a reply.


After a heavy sigh I pulled myself from the luggage compartment, hitting my head on the way out, just as I’d done when I fell in. My headache intensified, but I maintained my footing as I clambered out into the aisle.
I was not aware he had hit his head, needs to be clearer earlier please.

I looked up at the thin beam of light and yet again found myself gripped by the familiar compulsion to explore. My curiosity had returned. I carefully made my way to the rear of the bus, picking my way through the wreckage, hoping to find a fellow survivor but those I found were clearly dead. The young male passenger that had been thrown and knocked unconscious earlier had then been impaled by a sheet of twisted metal. There was no way to tell if it was part of the bus or just some other piece of debris, thrown violently in our direction. Either way, I doubted the man had any chance anyway. He had been unconscious at the time and then thrown around the interior of the bus like a ragdoll as it rolled. And it showed. His body was contorted in positions that defied the dexterity of any skeleton.
Very long, for me too much information.

The other passengers were no better off. As in, they were dead? And even in the low light, I could tell there was a lot of blood – all of it dry, of course. Why of course, would all the blood be dry, I have no idea of how much time has passed?

With my hopes of company Company? Is this a meeting/party? dashed, I made my way back towards the luggage area and the pinprick of light.

I needed out.

I stood on the nearby seat that was covered in glass and reached up. The ceiling of the bus was lower than before, crumpled and crushed, no doubt, by falling bricks and boulders. My hand touched the light. I savoured the moment before reaching further and eventually pulling myself up, using the seat to extend my reach. I moved cautiously at first, clearing aside what I could until the dread-filled pit of my stomach demanded otherwise – it demanded a speedy escape. Then, I clawed and clambered through dirt, rubble and something else, something stale and sickly. More and more pinpricks of light stabbed at my vision and I could feel blood on my hands, knees and face as I dug my way out. Until, at last, I emerged, and was immediately greeted by something that I did not expect, daylight. I expected daylight, you said there was light so I was not surprised. Also very long, again.

After being dazzled by sunlight, my vision cleared, only to reveal a sight that made me regret my escape. A bus with dead people, I’d be very happy to get out! Around me lay a scarred and battered landscape, a scene of complete desolation. Almost every building had been razed to the ground; burnt and mangled cars littered what was once a proud and popular city This is Scotland, well ok, a writers licence to create!!!! and everything was still and silent. But despite the destruction all around me, there were no raging infernos sweeping the landscape. Should there be inferno’s? No other movement or light, only a partially-clouded sun in the distance.



As I looked upon the broken Earth change to city before me, I realised – with disgust Not the emotion I had expected – at what had become both my tomb and my shelter what shelter/tomb is this the bus or city?. I had, of course, been buried among the rubble and the remains of a twisted and battered bus, Yes, you had said, repeating which in itself had fallen victim to the sheer brute force of the shockwave that had forced it from the road, onto the wide path and into the remains of a nearby building. How would you know all these details road/path if the building had fallen on the road/path?? Slabs of concrete and masonry had inevitably fallen on top, crumpling then crushing/confusing the roof of the bus and crushing see crumbling/confusing or pinning those unfortunate enough to be caught underneath. But it was the topsoil topsoil, I thought it was a city of that tomb that revealed to me the full extent of the destruction that had taken place here. The dead were everywhere. The unusual unusual?? stench that had filled my nostrils earlier earlier – has the smell gone? was from a sea of bodies that were laid out, as though on display, like a collection of felled trees. On top of all the buildings that have just fallen, so buildings fall then people come along and die later? Blood, puss, bile and the stink of decay filled the air and covered the ground.

My stomach immediately tried to surrender its contents but there was nothing to give. I was confused, weary, and half-mad it seemed seemed is a weak word here with thirst. I had no idea how long I had been unconscious in the bus or, Earlier in the piece, for a clearer timeframe please more importantly, if I was the only survivor. I pushed those thoughts to the back of my mind and looked upon the broken city before me.

In my destroyed surroundings, with little hope or optimism of my future, the one thing that I noticed about this dead world was – indeed – the lack of life, not just human life but everything. That was quick, he just got out of the bus!! There were no birds, rats, dogs or insects. There was no swarm of flies or even a single maggot to feast upon the countless dead that lay at my feet. There was nothing, only stillness and silence.

There is far too much information and descriptions being used which has allowed me to catch you on a lot of contradictions. I never really got much feeling from the character, but this could have been swamped by the wall of information you were trying to get across. The picture is an easy one, trust the reader to join some of the dots and not do all the work yourself. I think the above needs trimming down, it was a lot of writing considering all the guy had done was get out his bus. However, feel free to keep on bombing Scotland, they want out of the UK anyway!!!
Bowler1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2nd March 2012, 01:55 AM   #3 (permalink)
Registered User
 
David B's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Brighton and Hove
Posts: 143
Re: The Survivor - sci-fi (Chapter 2) Part 1

Your first recollections should be more physical, putting the reader into the wreck and maintaining a threat to the character i.e.:

I woke with a migraine and my face pressed into a metal floor. A sledgehammer had worked on my ribs, leaving me weak. Buried under fallen luggage, bruised lungs choked on dust-laden air, nagging me with the stench of spilt gasoline. The shuttle bus must have been in an accident that I couldn’t remember. Now any spark might torch its wreck, finishing what the crash had started.

After several unnerving minutes had passed...’ is too slow and dilutes the sense of danger. Let panic and adrenaline drive you back onto your feet.

Instead of ‘I could feel pieces of twisted metal protruding from everywhere...’ let a jagged edge cut exploring fingers to show your problems.

I looked towards the front of the bus and was shocked to see another pair of eyes staring back at me. They were blank and empty and clearly devoid of life. Below them was the barely recognisable sight of a uniform. It was the bus driver.’ – this is difficult to accept given earlier references to how dark the bus is. Consider your revulsion on blindly groping another corpse as an alternative.

I looked up at the thin beam of light and yet again found myself gripped by the familiar compulsion to explore. My curiosity had returned.’ This drops the reader out of the scene. You don’t need to rationalise your actions. Anyone would scramble for an exit. You don’t need detached curiosity.

I carefully made my way to the rear of the bus, picking my way through the wreckage, hoping to find a fellow survivor but those I found were clearly dead.’ Encountering corpses should have more impact i.e.:

Picking through the wreckage, my boots stopped scrunching on glass splinters and sank into something wet and squishy. Bile rose in my throat, leaving me grateful I couldn’t see my fellow passenger’s corpse in the darkness.

Unless you light up the bus, I’d save visual descriptions of corpses for those outside in the sunshine.

Describing your first sight of the holocaust is vital. i.e.:

After being dazzled by sunlight, my vision cleared, revealing a scarred and battered landscape. Every building had been razed to the ground while burnt and mangled cars littered Edinburgh’s ruins. Now only silence populated its scorched bricks and charred timbers. I touched my hair, fearing radiation sickness and stared at the ashes, searching for signs of radioactive fallout. Only a nuke or an asteroid strike could level a city.

At a time like this, some of your thoughts should run to friends or family buried under the rubble, making the scene more personal.
David B is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2nd March 2012, 02:36 PM   #4 (permalink)
ctg
weaver of the unseen
 
ctg's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Greater London
Posts: 2,856
Blog Entries: 1
Re: The Survivor - sci-fi (Chapter 2) Part 1

I like it. It's more fluid then the first chapter and I do wonder how much that has changed since you posted it here some months ago. I also would like to point out that you're improving. A great deal.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Flugel Meister View Post
The small shuttle bus – that had taken both me and the few other passengers that had boarded it to the city centre – or what was left of it, was seemingly bathed in darkness. My somewhat sluggish memory was then quickly and violently kicked into gear as I tried to move and my right hand touched the stitched-leather carrying handle of my suitcase.


You could try to shorten the end of the highlighted bit. I understand that you're foreshadowing an item that the character will be carrying for sometime. So just remove some of the description, please.

Quote:
The sights and sounds of the Scottish capital shot sharply into my mind and the dazzling display of light that had preceded the alarming tremors invited a barely subdued sense of panic back into the pit of my stomach.
It's a strange connection that you're building from touching the suitcase, and I do wonder if you could have tried to build up tension slightly differently, as the readers might have already guessed that this happened. Maybe you could try to use environmental description to set up the atmosphere (remember the character is in the bus, buried under heaps of God knows what).

Quote:
After several unnerving minutes had passed, I mustered the strength courage to move. My attempts were slow at first. In the blackness I could feel pieces of twisted metal protruding from everywhere and I came to the conclusion that this small and incredibly uncomfortable luggage compartment had ultimately saved me from being impaled by any number of objects: handrails, glass windows, or from being crushed like an insect in the wreck.


This paragraph is turned upside down. What you have at the bottom should come at the top as the characters finds out what happened. So I'd advice you to rethink on how you could write this passage. Also, which you're mustering? Courage or strength?

Quote:
In the darkness there was one thing that gave me hope, a small pinprick of light that shone like a heavenly beacon upon a section of the floor. As my eyes adjusted, I began to make out other details.


The eye sight is the most important sense, so if he's able to see then use that to your advance and deliver the description through that way.

Quote:
Shattered glass glittered on a nearby seat and there was grit and dirt everywhere.
If it's glittering then there's more light then a single ray.

Quote:
I looked towards the front of the bus and was shocked to see another pair of eyes staring back at me. They were blank and empty and clearly devoid of life. Below them was the barely recognisable sight of a uniform. It was the bus driver.

‘Help,’ I whimpered. ‘Can anyone hear me?’

Only the steady groan of twisted metal and falling dust provided a reply.


Nice.

Quote:
My hand touched the light. I savoured the moment before reaching further and eventually pulling myself up, using the seat to extend my reach.


Beautiful image.

Quote:
After being dazzled by sunlight, my vision cleared, only to reveal a sight that made me regret my escape.


I would consider removing whole sentence as it doesn't add up anything. Note, it's also mostly telling.

Quote:
As I looked upon the broken Earth before me, I realised – with disgust – at what had become both my tomb and my shelter.


No ****? I got that from the description. So please consider removing this telling bit.

Quote:
But it was the topsoil of that tomb that revealed to me the full extent of the destruction that had taken place here. The dead were everywhere.
We get that from the description, so please consider removing this bit.

Quote:
My stomach immediately tried to surrender its contents but there was nothing to give. I was confused, weary, and half-mad it seemed with thirst. I had no idea how long I had been unconscious in the bus or, more importantly, if I was the only survivor. I pushed those thoughts to the back of my mind and looked upon the broken city before me.


Think about moving this bit to the moment he crawls out from the bus and see the scorched earth around him.


ctg is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 5th March 2012, 12:36 PM   #5 (permalink)
Universe Builder
 
Flugel Meister's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Germany
Posts: 125
Re: The Survivor - sci-fi (Chapter 2) Part 1

Thanks, everyone. These critiques are vital and, as always, greatly appreciated.

I have actually finished the novel but am in the middle of editing it. But in order to have a firm foundation on which to build, I really need to nail the opening three chapters.

@Bowler
The previous chapter would have cleared up quite a few areas of concern, but there are still many valid points. In particular, the beam of light and the realisation that it’s daylight are areas that still need to be worked on.

@DavidB
Some very good points. I do need to make it that little bit more visceral and graphic in areas. There should be genuine revulsion and horror in the discovery of bodies.

@CTG
As always, a much needed guiding hand. I can see where things work now and where they don’t. I do plan on putting the first chapter up again for a second look.

The overall effect that I’m aiming for is:
  • Initial confusion. (Liam is a little dazed and confused when he wakes)
  • Sudden realisation. (As Liam touches the carrying handle of his suitcase, it all comes back)
  • Horror and revulsion. (Speaks for itself)
  • Shock and awe. (As Liam looks upon the world as it is after the event)
Some points will be cleared up later in the novel, others within the next chapter. But I am aiming for some confusion to remain with the reader, so that they genuinely feel as though they are in Liam’s shoes, or at least walking beside him. It is, after all, in the first-person.

I suppose I want the reader to go “WTF?” quite a few times throughout the story.
Flugel Meister is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:17 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.