| |||||||||
| Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Rate Thread |
| | #16 (permalink) |
| Mod of Awesome Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 3,634
| Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Well, you certainly don't have to info dump. For example when Mr. Gray is going off about where they sinned, Stargen could interject-- "On Hebon, we did what we had to do to protect our people. I know-" Stargen said, raising his hand to stop Mr. Gray from commenting again "-that what you did was nothing compared to what I did. But I didn't see you crying about our sins then. No, Gray. I saw you with the blood of children on your hands, taking as much joy from the destruction of those-what was the term you used back then? OH, yeah, those vile semi-human things. And now I come to you for confession, and you've come to blame me for all your choices and end my life. What about your own life, Mr. Gray? What about your sins? Are you prepared to face Hell without the absolution that comes from confession? Because I sure as freak am not." For an example, anyways, of how to keep up the pace and flow and story from their perspective. |
| | |
| | #18 (permalink) |
| Mod of Awesome Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 3,634
| Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) I'm only good in short spurts, I have no discipline or attention span. Plus, I've got like ten thousand projects going on right now, most of which are not even mine, but I'm always willing to help out when I have the time to so you can always message me. |
| | |
| | #22 (permalink) | |
| ...Prepare Thyself | Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Quote:
| |
| | |
| | #23 (permalink) | |
| Every day is Boxing Day! | Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Quote:
Like many shorts, it also feels like it might have a satirical point. Partly this might be the names - Adam, Stargen and Mr Gray all feel like ciphers, though they work. "Quirky" probably wasn't the best word, but I hope that explains why i used it. | |
| | |
| | #24 (permalink) | |
| ...Prepare Thyself | Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Quote:
| |
| | |
| | #25 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 13
| Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) I really like your approach. By quirky I think Harebrain means it's almost funny - line by line, in dialogue and in the image I get when reading it (the characters' poses, facial expressions etc). I agree with the multiple use of starting the sentences with Stargen near the beginning, it get's a little repetitive and made me wonder if it was done intenionally as a 'quirk'. I think Adam is great too, leave him in exactly how he is in my opinoin. Clarification on the killings I would expect to discover later on in the story, though I agree with dustingirlz question on why Stargen wants to give his confession (maybe this is a ruse in order to distract Mr Gray in order to kill him first, who knows) but as it is (even though a priest may want to confess) it seems a bit much after all the nasty stuff he's done. Gramatically it's good, and there's no pointless diatribe in my opinion. Well done. All just my opinion, I'm new at this so can't really claim to know much ![]() Best of luck |
| | |
| | #26 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 873
| Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Blackrook, good to see some of your work here. I think the critiquing has been done pretty well, but can I just say I really liked it? The tonality (for want of a better word) resonates well with me, and I also like the little humourous asides that show us Stargen's personality quirks. One thing, that piqued my curiosity: for long sections in the dialogue there's not a 'said' 'replied' etc in sight, but then suddenly they all crowd in. I followed the dialogue really easily (ok it's easy because there's only two of 'em in the room!) but I just wondered why that happened? Has someone already mentioned this. Let me look back and see....... Hmm, don't see it on this thread, and can't back out and read the others without losing this text. Ignore me if it's already been done and dusted! |
| | |
| | #27 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 338
| Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) I am glad to see the positive reaction. I agree the first paragraph which has too many "Stargens". That was actually a later edit. It was probably better as I first wrote it. I will change it back to the way it was. As HareBrain suspects, the names have meaning, but it would spoil it to tell you more. I am encouraged to post Chapter One, which you will find to be very different. |
| | |
| | #29 (permalink) |
| ...Prepare Thyself | Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Blackrook: When I said it was long I meant it was a long post to critique hence I stopped after the first dollop. As a piece the length was fine. Boneman: If you want to see a post that isn't on the page of posts you're viewing just right click on the page in the list in the (Page x of y < a|b|c|d |>| \/) link just above this window and click on open in a new window. The other alternative is to right click on post window (the text you're writing) and click on select all. Then Right click again on the highlighted text and click copy > sends it to the clipboard. Then if you loose the page you can always paste it back (right click and then paste) I always do the above when a post gets any length just in case you time out or accidentally change pages. |
| | |
| | #30 (permalink) |
| Mod of Awesome Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 3,634
| Re: Stargen Chronicles (Fourth Attempt) Generally people on the Internet have short attention spans. This isn't just for this critique site but all over the Internet. Its different than reading a magazine or book or newspaper. I wonder why that is? Hmm....mabye that will be my doctoral thesis in a few years when I get there? But, basically if its longer than 1000 words, people will just skim for whatever sticks out when it is online. |
| | |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Rate This Thread | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| the chronicles | cornelius | Critiques | 77 | 12th April 2006 04:40 PM |
| Loved Chronicles of Thomas Covenant, will i like Raymond E Feist's work? | schmintan | General Book Discussion | 24 | 17th December 2005 05:30 AM |
| Great Y A Authors From Chronicles Network Readers | Alia | Young Adult Fiction | 1 | 28th September 2005 06:20 PM |
| Lloyd Alexander: The Chronicles of Prydain & More | Alia | Young Adult Fiction | 2 | 31st August 2005 10:31 PM |