| |||||||
| Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism |
| |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Rate Thread |
| | #47 (permalink) |
| Ink-stained Wretch | Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! If you think you've reached the point where any more changes would misrepresent the book (and you are the only one who would know), I can only say that this is a huge improvement over the first synopsis we saw, and congratulations on producing something that you feel confident sending out. There are a few run-on sentences that need cleaning up, but you ought to be able to take care of that on your own. Now it just depends on whether an agent is drawn to this particular story or not. |
| | |
| | #48 (permalink) |
| There is only ME. Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 434
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Indeed. The only real gripe I had with it was Kataleena's part at the end. Since a synopsis is basically the story in a nut shell, I think even one tiny sentence can harm the flow of things. I know I wrote a lot before, but that is essentially all I was saying. I thought adding her into the synopsis took up space and knocked the internal conflict Jezzel had over being unfaithful to his wife out of focus. There's nothing wrong with having Kataleena in the story, but with so much limited space I personally wouldn't have made mention of her at the end of your synopsis. I thought there were other smaller issues, but I didn't think the synopsis was bad. Kataleena just made me kind of go... ???? because she popped out of nowhere at the end (a very important moment I'm guessing?) My initial thought after reading was that instead of adding Kataleena you could strengthen the synopsis by elaborating on the moment Jezzel told Roxy he wanted to move on with life. Like I said before, it seems like you have the makings of something nice here. You're on a good track. |
| | |
| | #49 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 54
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Thnaks C' for your considerd words. I do take your points and they are valued. Kataleena, I am umming' and erring' as she plays a small but significient role. It is her appearance, and what she brings, that makes Roxy choose to go back alone. And then it is this that makes Jez realise Roxy's importance to him, up to that point he had not been anything other than plutonical. Thanks again Steve. |
| | |
| | #50 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 54
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Ok Guys, I feel comfortable with this now. I hope you like this version. If you do it is largely thanks to your valued constructive input. Just one or two tweeks. (til Christmas lol). Steve Earth is in the grips of intense global warming, this mostly caused by humanity’s incessant materialistic choices. Ten thousand individuals, each with their own specialist field and selected in complete secrecy are to travel in two huge space arks. They have one job, one hope, to find an alternative planet, and start again. The ship’s they travel in have many self-sustaining eco systems, sufficient to aid their long and unpredictable journey. Some consider these ships, a modern day Noah’s ark. Selected, Jezzel discovers that due to a poorly contrived plan, his pregnant wife, Raqualla, is to travel on a different ark. This weighs heavy, emotionally, on both, but particularly for Jez, however having finally discussed this with Raq, they accept their offer in the belief their unborn baby may benefit. Now aboard, Jezzel joins Melinda’s small radio communication group, they soon form a close-knit team. During their journey, this group question the material values that lead them to this point. Ultimately, they decide to compile a new constitution for the future. On Quest 2, Jez finds himself attracted by Roxy, having an instant rapport, they become almost inseparable. Their closeness has the questioning attention of others in Melinda’s team. On a planet deep in the Milky Way, they discover a signal, emanating for thousands of years. Although this planet is now harshly uninhabitable, they expose tentative evidence, signifying man’s likely earlier existence. This raises deeply philosophical questions -- was this humanities original home, and, has this path been trodden before? After months in deep space, Quest 2 loses contact with the other ark. Many feel left in a void, concerned for their family on Quest 1. Most wanting to hear they are OK, for some the reality is harsher, however Jez, more philosophical, associates the need for closure. Their mood very quickly lifts, when, finding an idyllic planet, they start colonisation. A couple of months pass, and groups have settled well. Some groups are ready to spread further afield and Melinda’s team head north. There is still no contact with Quest 1. Jez seems strangely OK and declares he feels ready to move on with his life. Roxy, for so long blighted by her unrequited love of Jezzel, feels raised by this. However, soon after arriving at their encampment, new team member Kataleena is working closely with Jez. Roxy, now feeling surplus, makes a heart-wrenching choice to leave Jez behind, and head back to base camp. Disturbed, and waking in the middle of the night, and without provisions, she heads back to Jezzel. Alarmed to hear Roxy is on her way and suddenly stirring to her importance, Jez goes in search, when finally back together, they share the inner thoughts. |
| | |
| | #51 (permalink) | ||
| ...Prepare Thyself Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 720
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Now to the actual plot Quote:
Quote:
Deep inside the milky way (how, if it's some fantastic new space drive then global warming seems a little petty if science has advanced that much) Presumably some form of hibernation is involved and if so it should get a mention. Then again if hibernation is involved would a pregnant female go for it. Why does she need to be pregnant anyway. surely the chance to escape is reason enough to take the journey. Hope these are helpful and not discouraging | ||
| | |
| | #52 (permalink) |
| weaver of the unseen Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 669
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! TEIN, hibernation is not need if you can provide food and water source for the population that is under a controlled breeding scheme. You haven't read the book, so you don't know all the details. |
| | |
| | #53 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 54
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Thanks C' spot on. (again) ![]() He sits sipping his already cold cofee and thinks -- CRUMBS -- I know I'll write a book, or is it right, lol. ![]() Just a thought; would a 'hyper drive' fix the ozone, when it took the plants of the Silurion Epocque millions of years to create it>>> Just a thought Oh yeah -- Noah's ark -- ummm maybe it could be a tentative religious connotation, or even, dare I suggest, a realisation of the enormity of thier 'pilgrimage'. Steve |
| | |
| | #54 (permalink) | |
| Decent Imagination Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 65
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Quote:
I'm sure that Russell Davies or his predecessors didn't have any real world science behind the TARDIS, yet it is one of the most iconic craft from Science Fiction, because people BELIEVE that it can travel through Time and Space due to good writing. | |
| | |
| | #55 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 54
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Alcatraz, Love your comments, this is what I should have put. I was trying to be a little too diplomatic. I actually don't have a hyper anything, other than hopefully my imagination lol. As you so thoughtfully suggested, it is in the writing. I just give the impression in terms of days i.e. 86 days to get to Andromeda. Probably in the new 'Nissan GTR. He smiles contently to himself and heads back to his grammar. >>> Steve |
| | |
| | #56 (permalink) | |
| Registered User Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 185
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Quote:
| |
| | |
| | #58 (permalink) | ||
| ...Prepare Thyself Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 720
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Quote:
2ndchance: I assume you're joking about the 86 days to Andromeda Quote:
I would have thought a species that had mastered hyper drive would have solved the ozone problem before breakfast and still have change for a portion of fish and chips on the way home. | ||
| | |
| | #59 (permalink) | |
| There is only ME. Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 434
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! Quote:
Right now we can send people into space, but can't cure aids. If we can do one, should we be able to do another? Then there's the fact that some scientific discoveries actually help to harm the environment, like the atom bomb. The synopsis mentions that the environmental problems are man made, and could have much to do with their advanced discoveries in science. | |
| | |
| | #60 (permalink) |
| weaver of the unseen Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 669
| Re: OK Final vesrion 4 now! TEIN, true, it would be needed or then the ride would take a helluva long time. Then again, they might get a lucky and get a lift from Vorgon Construction fleet or finding a wormhole. Still, I raise my hands up. It's his book, not mine and it's not yours either. |
| | |