Science Fiction Fantasy
Science Fiction & Fantasy Portal:   |  HOME   |  FORUM   |   Other forums   |

 


Go Back   Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums > Books and Writing > Aspiring Writers > Critiques
Register Forum RULES Members List Gallery Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism


Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old 11th February 2008, 04:37 AM   #1 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: California
Posts: 6
The Truth About God - Part 1

Part 1.1

For most 24 year olds, life was going pretty fast. For Nathan however, life couldn't have possibly been moving any slower. Watching aimlessly as all his friends started their careers Nathan spent quiet nights alone endlessly dreaming about the future he was beginning to think would never come. For all his life he thought he was different. He knew at a young age that being special would somehow alienate him, and his present state spoke for itself. For years things just never seemed to go his way but he always held his head up. Although amazingly intelligent, he lacked a voice that people could connect with, even when what he said was what they wanted to hear. Such disappointment can be tough on a person, and in many ways this was true for Nathan. But something kept pushing him to wait it out. "Your day will come...." he always told himself. So at the start of a new semester in college, he opened up the course catalog, closed his eyes and pointed.

Keeping track of all the classes and career paths he had chosen over the last 6 years was nearly impossible. His latest bout at trying to be a novellist had ended with a major lack of motivation. Like always, the ideas trapped inside his head were too much for people to understand. It was as if his vision were so clear, people just saw right through it. One of the more obvious beliefs that set him apart was his lack of belief in a higher power. It never bothered him that he was an atheist, but it did set him apart from about 90% of the people he met. Either way, his destiny at least in his own mind was set, and one day he would acheive some level of greatness. To what extent, however, he had no clue. After deciding that photo/journalism was his next step to enlightenment, Nathan got comfortable in his usual spot on the couch and laid back for what he hoped would be a grueling night of Halo 2 on his XBOX360. He had recently picked up online gaming as a sort of outlet for all the upsets his current path kept leading him to, so tonight he planned on really "laying down the law," as he so graciously liked to say. Things were going his way for a change, at least in the game, when suddenly his 42" Samsung HDTV went spazo. Before the controller that fell from his hands as he lunged forward could hit the ground, he was on his hands and knees in front of the TV desperately searching for the source of his problems.

"God Damnit!!!!" he shouted.

"Who me? No thats my brother." a voice barely audible through the snow said.

After a quick glance at the beer he was drinking and trying to remember how many he had drank already..."I am so not tripping that hard." he said.

"Are you sure?" the voice from the TV said, louder this time.

And just then the TV went back to normal, GAME PAUSED staring Nathan right in the face once more. He looked at his beer again and scratched his head. "What is going on" he said to himself. A cigerette sounded perfect at that point and after trashing the Heineken he was drinking, he went out to the porch for just that. He had always thought of himself as a pretty observent guy. Even more so at picking out noises.( he had a thing for Music Production when he was 20.) He was almost positive the voice he heard was real but only a few minutes of rethinking and a little nicotine was going to help him now.
Cosmic24 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th February 2008, 04:42 AM   #2 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: California
Posts: 6
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

Part 1.2

The night was brisk and very quiet for a change. Living next to Interstate 5 was nice for Ocean views but horrible for noise. Strange though that at 11:30 on a saturday night things were as quiet as they were. Even the sound of his lighter igniting seemed like the only thing he could hear. The sound of a car whizzing past on the interstate in front of him eased his mind a bit as he took the last couple of drags off his cigerette. With one last puff he aimed at his favorite ash tray, the lone bush on his front porch, and fired away as usual. Just before he turned around however, the bush completely lit on fire in a quick burst and what almost looked like a face seemed to peer back at him through the flames. He would have thought he was dreaming if he hadn't slammed his head on his front door as he jarred backward from the fire. But as he looked around he could see that there was a couple in the parking lot not even 30 feet away that seemed clueless to what was happening. This realization suddely took over Nathan and in a sick panic he clumisly ran back into his apartment as fast as he could. He whipped around like lightning and slammed the door shut, locking it immidiately before he crouched down against the door sweating all over himself. Most people would have probably been on the brink of a mental break down at this point but not Nathan. Though fear in some way was definately a factor for him, he could only sort of sit there and laugh about it. Within in seconds Nathan was rolling around on the floor laughing so hard his stomach was hurting. That's when all the lights suddenly went out. As his laughter slowly died off the voice he had heard before started speaking again, and this time much more seriously.

"Look, I'd love to stay here and play games all night but I need your help Nathan of Earth."

"Nathan of Earth? What are you ruling more than one planet these days?"

"Hah, you're very funny, but Im not your supreme being, Im his brother."

"Ok what? I know I might be drunk but supreme gods with brothers too?
What have you been smoking Nathan?" he thought to himself. "Is this some kind of joke?" he asked aloud.


"Hmm, obviously God hasn't told your people of his existance yet, its actually very common, let me...."

"Woah woah woah there mist..eh... whatever the hell you are...First off, God has a lot of people on this planet doing all types of stupid things for him but Im not one of them. Secondly, its gonna take a lot more than some burning bush and messing up my TV to get me to believe anything I might be hearing right now is the truth."

"Hmm, are you sure God is making people do things for him? Like a king?"

"Well I wouldn't call it forcing but yes. In fact he's got about 3 or 4 big groups of people killing eachother daily over which way of worshiping him is right. It all makes me sick!"

"What you are explaining is something extremely against the laws of my council. The job of a supreme being is to protect and aid the life that inhabits the galaxies we preside over. Beyond that I know my brother to be incredibly tenacious at following the stirct guidelines of our work, so this really can't be true."

"Well it is, I hate to be the one to break it to you, but maybe your brother is not who you thought he was."


"No, it only further proves my original assumption. My brother, God, hasn't been here for a long time and no one has been alerted. Your people have seemingly come up with ideas of their own, and who knows what amounts of irreparairable damage has been done."

"You're telling me...Heh. Hey could you turn the lights back on? This is getting kind of creepy."


"Oh yes, I apologize." the voice replied. As the lights came on he continued, "So you might be wondering why I chose you Nathan, and for that I really can only say that you seemed like a good bet."

Something really strange was obviously at the bottom of all this, but on a boring and utterly depressing night such as this one, Nathan just sort of went a long for the ride as he and the so called Supreme Being continued to discuss the situation. According to the supreme being, who likes to be called Empyreal by the way, God and himself are part of an ancient group of supernatarual beings who's sole purpose is to serve and protect the galaxies of the universe; sort of like an intergalactic police/environmental protection force. He also proceeded to catch Nathan up on the most recent happenings that led him to Earth and explained the absolute necessity of finding out how and why God and possibly many other supreme beings were disappearing. For most people, sitting in their living room speaking to an invisible voice about gods and the universe would make them question their sanity. Nathan on the other hand loved it. It took him some getting used to at first, but the idea of an invisble being inviting him on a quest to save the universe was like winning the lottery. If it was really happening, this was the moment he had been waiting for his entire life. He couldn't help but laugh to himself...
Cosmic24 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th February 2008, 09:29 AM   #3 (permalink)
Nope, It's Definate
 
RodneyMcKay's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 117
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

Ok, so the one thing that got me about the paragraph was how he watchs his friends, yet you make it seem like he has been alienated all this time and wouldn't have made any friends.

And my own personal opinion... he is not very intelligent if he smokes (little thing that annoys me but if it part of you characterisation, I live with it)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cosmic24 View Post
Part 1.2

Within in seconds Nathan was rolling around on the floor laughing so hard his stomach was hurting.
Should just be within

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cosmic24 View Post
Something really strange was obviously at the bottom of all this, but on a boring and utterly depressing night such as this one, Nathan just sort of went a long for the ride as he and the so called Supreme Being continued to discuss the situation. According to the supreme being, who likes to be called Empyreal by the way, God and himself are part of an ancient group of supernatarual beings who's sole purpose is to serve and protect the galaxies of the universe; sort of like an intergalactic police/environmental protection force. He also proceeded to catch Nathan up on the most recent happenings that led him to Earth and explained the absolute necessity of finding out how and why God and possibly many other supreme beings were disappearing. For most people, sitting in their living room speaking to an invisible voice about gods and the universe would make them question their sanity. Nathan on the other hand loved it. It took him some getting used to at first, but the idea of an invisble being inviting him on a quest to save the universe was like winning the lottery. If it was really happening, this was the moment he had been waiting for his entire life. He couldn't help but laugh to himself...
This bit makes it seem like you've just desided you can't be bother with the conversation so you have thrown in a paragraph instead. Doesn't make the story flow so well.

Signing Out
Miss Rodney
RodneyMcKay is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th February 2008, 05:01 PM   #4 (permalink)
resident pedantissimo
 
chrispenycate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Switzerland
Posts: 2,415
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cosmic24 View Post
Part 1.1

For most 24 year olds, life was going pretty fast. For Nathan
comma
Quote:
however, life couldn't have possibly been moving any slower. Watching aimlessly as all his friends started their careers
comma
Quote:
Nathan spent quiet nights alone
comma
Quote:
endlessly dreaming about the future he was beginning to think would never come. For all his life he
"had" in here, and possibly without the "for" at the beginning of the sentence
Quote:
thought he was different. He knew at a young age that being special would somehow alienate him, and his present state spoke for itself. For years things just never seemed to go his way but he always held his head up. Although amazingly intelligent, he lacked a voice that people could connect with, even when what he said was what they wanted to hear. Such disappointment can be tough on a person, and in many ways this was true for Nathan. But something kept pushing him to wait it out. "Your day will come...." he always told himself. So at the start of a new semester in college, he opened up the course catalog, closed his eyes and pointed.
Quote:

Keeping track of all the classes and career paths he had chosen over the last 6 years was nearly impossible. His latest bout at trying to be a novellist had ended with a major lack of motivation. Like always, the ideas trapped inside his head were too much for people to understand. It was as if his vision were so clear, people just saw right through it. One of the more obvious beliefs that set him apart was his lack of belief in a higher power.
eliminate the repetition of "belief"?
Quote:
It never bothered him that he was an atheist, but it did set him apart from about 90% of the people he met. Either way, his destiny
commas setting off "at least in his own mind" but that sentence is clumsy
Quote:
at least in his own mind was set, and one day he would acheive some level of greatness. To what extent, however, he had no clue. After deciding that photo/journalism
Quote:
is that a slash, or photojournalism? was his next step to enlightenment, Nathan got comfortable in his usual spot on the couch and laid
lay
Quote:
back for what he hoped would be a grueling night of Halo 2 on his XBOX360. He had recently picked up online gaming as a sort of outlet for all the upsets his current path kept leading him to, so tonight he planned on really "laying down the law," as he so graciously liked to say. Things were going his way for a change, at least in the game, when suddenly his 42" Samsung HDTV went spazo. Before the controller that fell from his hands as he lunged forward could hit the ground, he was on his hands and knees in front of the TV desperately searching for the source of his problems.
Quote:

"God Damnit!!!!" he shouted.

"Who me? No thats my brother." a voice barely audible through the snow said.

After a quick glance at the beer he was drinking and trying to remember how many he had drank
drunk
Quote:
already..."I am so not tripping that hard." he said.
Quote:

"Are you sure?" the voice from the TV said, louder this time.

And just then the TV went back to normal, GAME PAUSED staring Nathan right in the face once more. He looked at his beer again and scratched his head. "What is going on" he said to himself. A cigerette sounded perfect at that point and
comma
Quote:
after trashing the Heineken he was drinking, he went out to the porch for just that. He had always thought of himself as a pretty observent
observant
Quote:
guy.
[color=red]Perhaps ""especially" as you've not specified what it's more than[color]
Quote:
Even more so at picking out noises.( he had
he had had a thing
Quote:
a thing for Music Production when he was 20.) He was almost positive the voice he heard was real but only a few minutes of rethinking and a little nicotine was going to help him now.
chrispenycate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th February 2008, 05:31 PM   #5 (permalink)
resident pedantissimo
 
chrispenycate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Switzerland
Posts: 2,415
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cosmic24 View Post
Part 1.2
Quote:
The night was brisk and very quiet for a change. Living next to Interstate 5 was nice for Ocean views but horrible for noise. Strange though that
comma
Quote:
at 11:30 on a saturday night
comma
Quote:
things were as quiet as they were. Even the sound of his lighter igniting seemed like the only thing he could hear. The sound of a car whizzing past on the interstate in front of him eased his mind a bit as he took the last couple of drags off his cigerette. With one last puff he aimed at his favorite ash tray, the lone bush on his front porch, and fired away as usual. Just before he turned around
comma
Quote:
however, the bush completely lit on fire in a quick burst and what almost looked like a face seemed to peer back at him through the flames. He would have thought he was dreaming if he hadn't slammed his head on his front door as he jarred backward from the fire. But as he looked around he could see that there was a couple in the parking lot not even 30 feet away that seemed clueless to
"clueless to" sounds a bit strange. "clueless as to" perhaps
Quote:
what was happening. This realization suddely
suddenly
Quote:
took over Nathan and in a sick panic he clumisly
clumsily
Quote:
ran back into his apartment as fast as he could. He whipped around like lightning and slammed the door shut, locking it immidiately
immediately, comma
Quote:
before he crouched down against the door
comma
Quote:
sweating all over himself. Most people would have probably been on the brink of a mental break down
breakdown
Quote:
at this point but not Nathan. Though fear in some way was definately
definitely
Quote:
a factor for him, he could only sort of sit there and laugh about it. Within in seconds Nathan was rolling around on the floor laughing so hard his stomach was hurting. That's when all the lights suddenly went out. As his laughter slowly died off the voice he had heard before started speaking again, and this time much more seriously.

"Look, I'd love to stay here and play games all night but I need your help
comma
Quote:
Nathan of Earth."

"Nathan of Earth? What
comma
Quote:
are you ruling more than one planet these days?"

"Hah, you're very funny, but Im not your supreme being, Im
I'm
Quote:
his brother."

"Ok what? I know I might be drunk but supreme gods with brothers too?
What have you been smoking Nathan?" he thought to himself. "Is this some kind of joke?" he asked aloud.


"Hmm, obviously God hasn't told your people of his existance yet, its
it's
Quote:
actually very common, let me...."

"Woah woah woah there mist..eh... whatever the hell you are...First off, God has a lot of people on this planet doing all types of stupid things for him but Im
I'm
Quote:
not one of them. Secondly, its
it's
Quote:
gonna take a lot more than some burning bush and messing up my TV to get me to believe anything I might be hearing right now is the truth."

"Hmm, are you sure God is making people do things for him? Like a king?"

"Well I wouldn't call it forcing but yes. In fact he's got about 3 or 4 big groups of people killing eachother daily over which way of worshiping him is right. It all makes me sick!"

"What you are explaining is something extremely against the laws of my council. The job of a supreme being is to protect and aid the life that inhabits the galaxies we preside over. Beyond that I know my brother to be incredibly tenacious at following the stirct guidelines of our work, so this really can't be true."

"Well it is,
period
Quote:
I hate to be the one to break it to you, but maybe your brother is not who you thought he was."


"No, it only further proves my original assumption. My brother, God, hasn't been here for a long time and no one has been alerted. Your people have seemingly come up with ideas of their own, and who knows what amounts of irreparairable damage has been done."
either "amount…has“ or “amounts…have"
Quote:

"You're telling me...Heh. Hey could you turn the lights back on? This is getting kind of creepy."


"Oh yes, I apologize." the voice replied. As the lights came on he
possibly "it" rather than "he" (referring to the voice, and removing gender information on the deity
Quote:
continued, "So you might be wondering why I chose you Nathan, and for that I really can only say that you seemed like a good bet."

Something really strange was obviously at the bottom of all this, but on a boring and utterly depressing night such as this one, Nathan just sort of went a long
along
Quote:
for the ride as he and the so called Supreme Being continued to discuss the situation. According to the supreme being, who likes to be called Empyreal by the way, God and himself are part of an ancient group of supernatarual beings who's sole purpose is to serve and protect the galaxies of the universe; sort of like an intergalactic police/environmental protection force.
whyis this sentence in present tense when the rest is past?
Quote:
He also proceeded to catch Nathan up on the most recent happenings that
had
Quote:
led him to Earth and explained the absolute necessity of finding out how and why God
comma
Quote:
and possibly many other supreme beings
comma - and you've painted yourself into a corner with the continous "disappearing" – there is no evidence given that god has not been disappeared for some considerable time, in human terms.
Quote:
were disappearing. For most people, sitting in their living room speaking to an invisible voice about gods and the universe would make them question their sanity. Nathan on the other hand loved it. It took him some getting used to at first, but the idea of an invisble being inviting him on a quest to save the universe was like winning the lottery. If it was really happening, this was the moment he had been waiting for his entire life. He couldn't help but laugh to himself...
chrispenycate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th February 2008, 09:57 PM   #6 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: California
Posts: 6
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

2 Chrispenycate,
Hey thanks a lot for the grammar work. I may need to hire you as my editor from now on. But the real question is, what did you think of what you read? Does this it seem interesting to you? A lot of my ideas are really out there, so Im always asking... :P
Cosmic24 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12th February 2008, 10:55 PM   #7 (permalink)
resident pedantissimo
 
chrispenycate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Switzerland
Posts: 2,415
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

I generally don't comment on style, as my taste does not necessarily line up with anyone else's. So I point out the punctuation and grammar, because it's something I can do, might even help, and informs you somebody has read through your piece attentivrly, from beginning to end (very annoying when there are no responses, positive or negative, isn't it?)

So, what I found was that I didn't empathise with your central character, and I should. The description, apart from the amazing intelligence and the smoking, hits very close to home (and, I suspect, matches a faily large percentage of Chronicals). I should feel that, if I happened to have a divine visitation, that would be me.
Now, you can claim that he is far enough of the norm that I can't be expected to feel like him; but some authors can make me feel really warped characters, and care about what happens to them.
However, I can't translate this into word order or rhythm, or anything I know how to explain, and anyway, I'm strange; my views are not frequently those of anyone else.
chrispenycate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13th February 2008, 03:45 AM   #8 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Montana
Posts: 21
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

The brother of God talking to somebody who feels vaguely "chosen"...through a sputzy television signal.

This idea has real potential.

At this stage of your writerly maturation, you have some bad habits. You idea, however, has blood and oxygen and electricity. William Gaddis would've used it. He died without a much-deserved Nobel. He too was vaguely chosen.

Now...how does one spot, much less get rid of, bad habits?...after all, get rid of the bad habits, and we have an idea with blood and oxygen and electricity that a Nobel-robbed illuminati would've used...
buskydudd is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th February 2008, 03:20 AM   #9 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: California
Posts: 6
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

thanks for the comment Buskydudd. I know I have bad habits and I'm trying daily to rid myself of them. Sometimes it's laziness, sometimes I just loose track of where I was going. Its all part of the process though Im sure.

Besides that, im very happy that you see the potential of this story even in its infant stages. Hopefully I wont skew away too far from what you like about it.

In a nut shell, an alien named Empyreal (a galactic protector) has just lost his assigned Galaxy to a collision with another galaxy. He then sets off to find his brother God who might have answers to why he wasnt notified before the collision, but when he reaches the Milky Way(God's assigned galaxy) he finds that God has disappeared. In search of answers, he makes contact with an earth man named Nathan, an atheist who has lost his way in life. Together they will travel the universe searching for God and the other missing protectors to save the universe from impending doom; encountering all types of amazing obstacles on the way. (ancient alien ruins, far more advanced civilizations, "MIND Games", etc.)

Intersting concepts-
In this world, Religion will be debunked but God will exist.
AND
The way scientists see the universe will be correct but we find that it can be manipulated on a large scale for long-term sustainability.

Hope this sounds fun, cuz Im having a blast writing it.
Cosmic24 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18th February 2008, 12:13 PM   #10 (permalink)
Nope, It's Definate
 
RodneyMcKay's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 117
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

I think it is really good idea for a story! Have fun writing it!
RodneyMcKay is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18th February 2008, 06:29 PM   #11 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Greater London
Posts: 149
Re: The Truth About God - Part 1

Start with the line "God dammit!"

Everything before that point is irrelevant info-dumping. Move it to chapter 15. If it doesn't work there, delete it.
The Curious Orange is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
9.19 / 9.20 : The Truth (parts 1 & 2.) Dave X-Files and Lone Gunmen 43 28th September 2007 01:42 PM
9/11 what do you think? Vladd67 World affairs 39 14th September 2007 04:26 PM
City of Chaos -- a FK fic EmilyH Forever Knight 6 25th November 2002 09:36 PM
Memory Soup EmilyH Critiques 5 6th September 2002 10:33 AM
Star Trek Victory: PILOT (Part One) Blooded Star Trek Fan Fiction 12 27th October 2001 09:08 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:49 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0 ©2008, Crawlability, Inc.

About | Link To Us | For Writers | For Publishers | Privacy | Terms of Use | Copyright | Press | XML/RSS | Contact Us

© Copyright Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles 2003-2008