| |||||||
| Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism |
| |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Rate Thread |
| | #1 (permalink) |
| Half-elf Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 24
| The Empty Map - Chapter 1 Excerpt This is an excerpt from the very beginning of a book I am co-writing with Amber Whitney. Things we would like you to comment on if you could: Is it interesting and intriguing? Do you want to read more? Is it too confusing or does is turn you off in any way? Are there any areas where the writing sounds clunky? Things like that would really help out out. Tanwil brushed a finger over the faded scar as he stared ahead. The light breeze in the forest made the sweat prickling the back of his neck feel cold. Barin knelt beside him, jostling the small bush next to him. “Have to be quick,” Barin muttered, staring at the wall. The old man kept his grip tight on the sword at his side. Tanwil didn’t have to look to know Barin was rubbing the insignia on the hilt. Past the dense forest where they hid was a stone wall, at least fifteen feet high. Tanwil raised his eyes, gazing at the tips of the trees beyond the wall. The peculiar blue leaves swayed in the same breeze that bothered Tanwil’s neck. He traced his scar again. It went from his forehead to the curve of his chin on the left side of his face, nearly as wide as his thumb. The wound had nearly sealed his eye shut, but his eyesight was still fair. It had however left him with a perpetual squint, and women who always sat to his right. Tearing his eyes away from the Grove, Tanwil looked over his shoulder. “Is Egund ready?” “He’ll do what needs to be done.” “It’s going to hurt.” Barin didn’t respond. There was no need, they both knew the price Egund had to pay for them. The old man stood, turned and walked back to their makeshift camp. Tanwil followed, counting the paces in his head from the tree line to the group. It wouldn’t make any difference if he knew how many paces it was from there to the wall, but he did it anyways. Maldin and Fenlar stood aside with the horses, while Egund paced a rut in the ground. Dark rings hung under Egund’s eyes. For the past two nights the elf had looked like a man haunted. Under normal circumstances, Barin would have demanded that Egund rest properly so he wouldn’t be a danger to the group. But these were not normal circumstances, and Barin would not make any more demands of Egund. Barin took an unlit torch from his saddlebag and handed it to Tanwil. Giving the wooden torch a squeeze, Tanwil disciplined his face into a blank mask. Showing fear would only make it worse for the younger elf, but in the back of his mind he was thanking the Danae that it wasn’t him. “Egund. It’s time.” The youth looked up from his pacing, and Tanwil forced himself to ignore the fear he saw in those eyes. He gestured with the torch, waiting for the boy to come to him. Shaking his hands out, Egund took a few uncertain steps forward and stood in front of Tanwil. The young elf raised his hands, holding his trembling fingers above the torch. A bead of sweat crept from his temple into the collar of his jerkin. Nothing happened. They stood in silence waiting for Egund. Tanwil’s patience began wearing thin. They didn’t have long until the guards came around the wall again. Somewhere, Barin cleared his throat. There was a sharp crack in the air, like bottled thunder. Violet flames sprung to life at the end of the torch, and Tanwil snatched it back. Egund lurched forward, his face twisted in agony. Before he dropped to the ground, Barin caught him. The old man covered Egund’s mouth, stifling the elf’s screams. Egund’s body began convulsing violently while he howled into Barin’s hand. The old man managed to keep his hold despite the struggle. Barin looked at Tanwil, the old man’s eyes dropping on him like weights. And Tanwil ran. Thanks for reading! |
| | |
| | #2 (permalink) |
| Sympathy for the Devil Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 375
| Re: The Empty Map - Chapter 1 Excerpt Didn't really get much from it, it's not exactly something to suck me in. It doesn't really describe the characters too well, and there's no idea of what's going on. From this sample alone, I'm not sure I'd read any further.... |
| | |
| | #3 (permalink) |
| Moderator Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 4,963
| Re: The Empty Map - Chapter 1 Excerpt Sorry, I disagree. If this is the very beginning of the book, I'd say it's very good...nicely paced, intriguing, and setting up lots of questions that I'd want to know the answers to... I assume that we'll be going on to either a flashback which will explain what's happing, or some development...but as a teaser, I thought it worked. Oh, and not at all clunky..... |
| | |
| | #5 (permalink) |
| Lost Boy Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 3,065
| Re: The Empty Map - Chapter 1 Excerpt I'd agree with Py is Ys, it's a neat litle piece that holds the attention. If I had a criticism it would be that I found it a little hard to follow who was who and who was saying what, but I did read it quickly, so the fault may be mine. Also, the end was a little confusing, but I guess that will be cleared up furhter on. Still, there may be room for a little expansion throughout. |
| | |
| | #6 (permalink) |
| Half-elf Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 24
| Re: The Empty Map - Chapter 1 Excerpt Thanks for the input everyone, I'm glad to hear that most of you like it. As I am sure you can guess, you will figure out later on just exactly what these guys are up too, and why Egund was in so much pain after the spell. I will probably be posting so more excerpts later on, so if you are still interested, keep an eye out! |
| | |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Rate This Thread | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| excerpt from chapter 1.... | chopper | Critiques | 10 | 28th November 2007 08:25 PM |
| Luna Rising - Chapter 2 excerpt | RAGordon | Critiques | 11 | 16th December 2006 10:54 AM |
| Excerpt from Chapter 5: Acsension | dustinzgirl | Critiques | 0 | 11th June 2006 09:41 AM |