| |
|
| |||||||
| Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Rate Thread |
| | #1 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Tyne and Wear
Posts: 4
| Sacred Wing Prologue Hi all ... I already posted this once, but for some reason it didn't appear. Anyway, just wanted a little constructive feedback on this prologue I'm working on at the minute - just wanting to see if I'm on the right lines ![]() Yes, I'm not happy with the overly cliché ending, for the moment it's just "an ending". Anyway, any constructive criticism would be helpful, thanks! |
| | |
| | #3 (permalink) |
| Young Writer Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 15
| Re: Sacred Wing Prologue I found this pretty interesting. I especially like Rai's imagination and creativity. Some corrections and suggestions are in red, if you care to look at my two cents: Prologue The sun was shining down on Rai as he relaxed on the beach in his makeshift deckchair made from discarded plastic bottles and ropeweed. It smelled a little funky, but at least it was comfortable-ish (Get rid of the ish. Makes it seem unprofessional. If you must, find another way to describe kind of comfortable), or at least it would be if there weren’t a bottlecap sticking into his kidney. He sat there a moment and wondered if he might be mistaken for a crazy person. The image of a muttering hermit with an overemphasised (overemphasized) limp gathering flotsam popped into his mind, which amused him briefly, then came to the conclusion that yes, he most likely would be confused for someone a little bit special if the situation was actually happening. Rai opened his eyes and left the tiny world that he had created in his mind, and turned over in his tiny (You already used tiny in this sentence, so it would be best to find another adjective) cabin bed. His designated cube looked as though as if (Not sure what you mean here. Either "as though" or "as if", or maybe "as though if". But it doesn't make sense this way) you were to ask it what it wanted to be when it grew up it would reply to you, like a child dressed up as a fireman, with such aspiration and an almost awe inspiring, glassy-eyed gaze that it wanted to be a garbage dump (Too many clauses. Seems to run on for too long. Try to get rid of or combine some of them) Rai never liked to throw things out, his walls were covered in pictures of other people's love interests and families, letters from home, and postcards from distant worlds he'd never even heard of, and in some cases even doubted their existence entirely. The round faced, moustachioed (mustachioed) man rubbed the grimy, circular window with his overall sleeve to be greeted by darkness. “Hello” said the darkness, cheerfully. Rai grunted in reply and closed the shutter, now was not the time to be socialising (socializing) with literal personifications. (I find these first three sentences hilarious. Great job ) Today was going to be a day where absolutely nothing of any interest whatsoever happens, just like any other day on this heap of scrap metal they called a warship. 'Harmony', they named it. Irony wasn't one of Rai's strong points, but he was sure he would have appreciated it had he taken the time to discover the importance of a personality.As he sat up and wandered over to his grubby mirror, he saw himself as one usually does when looking at a highly polished reflective surface. Rai Baron, Maintenance Technician hash one three six, subjunctions fifteen through twenty-three B, decks nine through twelve, jump shaft maintenance, shafts Beta and Gamma-Forward (This sentence is a bit heavy on information. Try to slim it down a bit). Rai gave himself a half-hearted salute. His mirrored double returned the salute with a hearty smile and a vigorous flick just to be friendly, not that it was particularly necessary to salute at all since they were of the same rank. He looked happy and clean shaven with a nice haircut. The world seemed so much finer beyond the glass. The Rai on the outside, however, with his unkempt hair, face like sandpaper, and what might be mistaken for a furry slug over his lip, felt quite neutral, as if a fog of beige soup mix had somehow sat itself around him with the sole purpose of absorbing his emotions. Perhaps it was chicken and mushroom. Suddenly Rai knew exactly what he was to have for lunch. |
| | |
| | #4 (permalink) |
| Causa Scientiae Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Dundee City
Posts: 2,008
| Re: Sacred Wing Prologue I have to point out that two of the spelling changes you have suggested are in fact Americanisations of the English language. American English is fine, but xenon has actually spelled two of those words correctly (overemphasised;socialising). Anyway, sorry to be a pain... |
| | |
| | #5 (permalink) |
| Registered User Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Tyne and Wear
Posts: 4
| Re: Sacred Wing Prologue Excellent, Thanks for your input ![]() All of the grammatical errors will be updated in the next revision, thanks for pointing those out, Clavitz. The only point I'd like to question is in the final paragraph, where you replaced "The Rai in the mirror" with "His mirrored double". I kinda wanted to give the impression that Rai and Mirror Rai are completely different entities. I do this by referring to both Rais as "Inside" and "Outside" the mirror. Also, the overextended technical introduction. This was intentional, insofar as to give the job as a Janitor appear little more self-important, at least in Rai's mind. Maybe I should go about this a different way. |
| | |
| | #6 (permalink) |
| Pain: the best teacher. Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Norfolk
Posts: 557
| Re: Sacred Wing Prologue Super, really liked it, Felt as though I could be there, perhpas because I find a smidgeon of myself in RAi ...... Keep it up lots of promise All the best Jez. |
| | |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Rate This Thread | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Needs Critiques* 2nd book prologue | Damiynn | Critiques | 7 | 31st August 2007 12:15 AM |
| Shot at a prologue... | Funngunner | Critiques | 3 | 25th August 2007 12:10 AM |
| [Work in Progress] Novel Prologue | PenDragon | Critiques | 4 | 15th February 2005 02:25 PM |
| Justice League ideas | demolition18 | The Lounge | 0 | 14th June 2004 01:50 AM |
|
| About | Link To Us | For Writers | For Publishers | Privacy | Terms of Use | Copyright | Press | XML/RSS | Contact Us © Copyright Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles 2003-2008 |