Deathly Hallows - who's going to die?

[Majimaune]

Ahh right, thats where its from. Thanks Hoopy.

[HBP]

Thats odd never seen that before seriously, My friends and i sad at school discussing the death and it just sorta popped in my head. Well i guess great minds think alike, and since your theory was made pubicly before mine i guess you could call that copyright infringement.

[tangaloomababe]

I am putting my money on Dumbledore or Snape. I cant see it being Hagrid or Hermione. Only time will tell I guess.

[Joel007]

If Rowling isn't intending to write any more books set in that world, she can do whatever she wants. I'm hoping for a Cameo by Cthulhu!

[HoopyFrood]

Oh, that would be brilliant! Lunging up out of the lake and dragging Harry, Ron and Hermione back into the depths, kicking and screaming. Oh yes, absolutely.

[Majimaune]

Yes that would work very well.

[idioteque04]

ron is a goooooooone.

[Majimaune]

No I don't think Ron is gone. He is too central.

[zatchstar90]

mabey Dobey will come back and warn harry to go back to school like his mother wanted. then harry gets angry and kills him off. LOL. so much for the sock.

[zatchstar90]

Sorry about the last one, could not help my self!

looking at anothert thread i have come up with a thought, Harry finds out that he is the last remaining horcurux and decides to commit suicide for the good of the wizarding world! how heroic!

[Majimaune]

We have alread discused that Zatch (can I call you that its just shorter) If he does commit suicide it will be so as to take Voldie with him.

And he wont commit suicide, JK doesn't have the heart to kill him.

[Joel007]

There's a whole different feel to Harry killing Voldie in a duel, vs Harry killing himself and maybe taking Voldie with him. Anyway, even if he was a Horcrux (which would be highly improbable and very tacky), he couldn't be certain that he was the last one.
I think given the trend of relying on your friends as much as your own courage, Harry will appear to be alone, but end up having a lot of resources to draw on which he hadn't counted on.

[Majimaune]

He will think he is alone, other will follow him, maybe the whole ministry of magic (doubt it) and Voldie kills them all. It would be about time evil won in a fantasy noval.

[Joel007]

Read Ian Irvine then Both sides have equal chances

[HBP]

Originally Posted by HBP

Probably this is not the best thread for what i am about to say but since it concerns death i will............... there's something so fishy about Dumbledores death. Dumbledore was always so convinced that death is olny another journey and yet upon his, he begs for mercy. I think he was actually begging snape to go out with there plan.

I believe that Dumbledore and Snape planned the entire thing from the curse of the ring to the death of Dumbledore. It is a theory of mine that they were trying to thwart the death curse which resulted in the injury on dumbledores hand. They became succesful in the end as Dumbledore wanted to be removed from the spotlight. For a feasible reason as why he would want to do this is certainly not clear to me.......probably it is a means to do undercover search for the rest of the horcruxes.

To help support the above theory, this is something i considered. Everytime Fawkes the phoenix sense that Dumbledore and persons close to Dumbledore is in mortal danger he shows up. Why did he not appear to try and save Dumbledore as he did when Voldemort sent the killing curse after Dumbledore and as he did in the Chamber of Secrets. That is because he was ordered not to. There are too many things supporting the idea that Dumbledore is still alive. JK would certainly not leave the death open to so many possibilities that Dumbedore is still alive.