Earthsea

[The Wanderer]

Well having read the quartet, I like the series very much, I felt the strongest was 'The Farthest Shore'...

Any thoughts welcome

[Fried Egg]

I've only read the original trilogy...is the fourth one worth reading?

[j. d. worthington]

Perhaps I shouldn't speak up here, not having read Tehanu myself but... from the accounts I've heard from people who have -- yes. Albeit it's a distinct shift, and more mature in approach (as befits the world, the characters, and LeGuin's own growth as a writer). Also, there are two other books in the Earthsea set: Tales from Earthsea (2001) and The Other Wind (2001). One of these is a story collection. There are also a couple of Earthsea stories in her collection, The Wind's Twelve Quarters, "The Word of Unbinding" and "The Rule of Names". Below is a link to a chronology for the series:

Earthsea - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[Teresa Edgerton]

Fried Egg -- The fourth and fifth ones, and some of the short stories, essentially rip the first three to pieces. There are things about Tehanu that I admire very much, but I didn't find it altogether satisfying, and The Other Wind struck me as a very weak effort for an author of LeGuin's calibre.

She obviously felt that she had important things to say and she was able to communicate them with some power in Tehanu but even there I wished she had chosen a new series and a new setting in which to say them and left Earthsea alone. And from that point on the axe-grinding seems to repeatedly get in the way of the storytelling.

For whatever flaws there are in the first trilogy, they strike me as books arising directly from the artistic impulse and the joy of creation, the others keep whispering the dread word agenda in my ear. I don't lack sympathy for that agenda, but ... as I said, I wish she had chosen some other place than Earthsea to advance it.

Wanderer -- I've learned to appreciate The Farthest Shore more with subsequent readings, but it's a toss-up between Wizard and Atuan which one I love the best. The prose in all three books really sings, and I feel that LeGuin has the ability to say more in fewer words than practically any author writing today.

JD -- The short story collection is Tales from Earthsea. It has some new stories and some old ones.

[Who's Wee Dug]

I did not enjoy Tombs as much as Wizard and Farthest Shore not to say I disliked it but it didn't grab me as much, maybe a little bit of middle book syndrome and I have Tehanu, Tales, and Other Wind in my yet to read pile.

[Teresa Edgerton]

Originally Posted by Who's Wee Dug

a little bit of middle book syndrome

And yet Tehanu was, in earlier editions, subtitled "The Last Book of Earthsea." She clearly meant it to wrap up the whole series and didn't plan any sequels.

In the end, though, it seems she agreed with you and decided that what she had was incomplete.

[The Wanderer]

Originally Posted by Fried Egg

I've only read the original trilogy...is the fourth one worth reading?

I would say yes, classic fantasy lovers may be frustrated and unstatisfied though, On a personal level, I thought it was great

[Fried Egg]

Originally Posted by The Wanderer

I would say yes, classic fantasy lovers may be frustrated and unstatisfied though, On a personal level, I thought it was great

Would you care to elaborate on this?

[The Wanderer]

Originally Posted by Fried Egg

Would you care to elaborate on this?

Well the main characters struggle with loss and conscience rather than enguaging with enemies, I recommend it though, the ending is handled with consumate skill

[Saltheart]

It's true. The epic climax with Ged and his shadow confronting and the Jungian concept of the self worked delightfully. I was tingling all over at that simple, one word confrontation--far more excited than any amount of explosions or killing or coming back from the dead of any fantasy novel. That inner struggle--simple, not externalized, swift--delivered the best climax I've read in any fantasy novel my whole life.

EDIT: Doh. Thought you were explaining the first one, not the fourth, the only one I didn't read.

[The Wanderer]

Originally Posted by Saltheart

It's true. The epic climax with Ged and his shadow confronting and the Jungian concept of the self worked delightfully. I was tingling all over at that simple, one word confrontation--far more excited than any amount of explosions or killing or coming back from the dead of any fantasy novel. That inner struggle--simple, not externalized, swift--delivered the best climax I've read in any fantasy novel my whole life.

EDIT: Doh. Thought you were explaining the first one, not the fourth, the only one I didn't read.

She's never had any problems finishing novels, IMO, even some other great Science Fiction Authors have

[akhc]

it's actually a sextet now. or as I prefer the 1st and 2nd Earthsea trilogies since the two are written from completely different perspectives (imo).

FWIW I enjoyed the Farthest Shore of the first 3 books the most though Wizard of Earthsea ran it close.