The UK's largest Science Fiction & Fantasy Forums

Go Back   Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums > Books and Writing > Aspiring Writers > Critiques



Critiques Post your writing here for critique and constructive criticism

Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old 28th December 2006, 06:23 PM   #1 (permalink)
Maiden of Hallian
 
Enadil Moonweaver's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 71
Chapter three of legacy Rewrite.

Chapter 3: The Mystery of the Symbols.

During the night, a small group came to Griffin air. They were travelers who had been in Ursatavia during the time of the Magick Ceremony. With them was a young girl she was among the few mages that were chosen but she had left during the festival so she did not talk to the Magick tester.

Nigel had let them in and talked with them until the sun came up. Upon hearing the voices, Mia and the others got up from their rooms groggily.

“Uncle, care to introduce us to these people?” questioned Azerath.

The small child looked at Azerath with wide inquisitive eyes and spoke in Kalnabian.
“My name is Neyuki Sanpuku, sorry to wake you sir.”

Azerath stared at the girl when she mentioned her name, “Sanpuku? You’re a merchant’s daughter right? The one from the festival.”

Neyuki nodded, “That is correct sir.”

Mia grinned, “You have had fun at the festival. Especially since I heard your name called.”

Neyuki nodded again, “Yes, I was chosen to go to the Magick School, but my islands leader wants me to go to the Crystal Spire Guild first.”

Arien asked aloud “Don’t you think it’s weird. That both of the leaders said we had to go to the Crystal Spire Guild?”

Everyone in the room looked at each other. It was weird. Why had the young mages been chosen? Why did they have to go to the guild? It was as if the leaders knew more than they were sharing. Mia thought a bit and then ran to the room that her, Rose and Arien were sharing.

Neyuki grew curious , “Where did that girl go off to?”

Azerath, “Oh, Mia? I think she went back to her room to get something. By the way, my name’s Azerath. The other two girls are Arien and Rose.”

Mia returned to the room carrying the Communication sphere that Adenydd had given her. Crossing the room, she put it on a table. Mia began to concentrate and said.

“I need to speak to Adenydd of Ursatavia.”

Slowly the sphere grew brighter as Adenydd’s face appeared upon it’s surface.

“Oh Mia, What‘s wrong?” asked Adenydd.

“There is more than going to the guild isn’t there Ma’am.”

Sighing Adenydd replied, “I was hoping you wouldn’t figure it out until you got there.”
She bowed her head for a moment and then looked at them, “There is a Prophecy of the world falling to darkness.”

Mia nodded, “I know the prophecy you speak of.” She began to recite the prophecy;

“A world will fall to shadows darkness and despair.
A golden maiden will suffocate from darkness’ touch.
Heroes from far and wide will be the light of hope.
Guided by loyalty and faith one will betray will others remain true.
They shall journey to the heart of the world and free the light from the dark.”

Adenydd nodded, “That is correct Mia. A few nights ago, I had a prophetic dream. It told me who the Heroes would be. The ones marked with the Elemental symbols of Mana.”

“You mean, Us?” inquired Mia.

“Yes I do. Please forgive me I had no choice but to send you.”

“Why do you ask of forgiveness Ma’am?” Mia was slightly puzzled.

“Because it may already be too late, but you have to try. You cannot just give up. Prophecy states that you will be the Heroes. All of us here in Ursatavia believe in you.”

With Adenydd’s words the Communication sphere’s picture faded. Sextet looked at each other in wonder. The mystery of the symbols had been revealed. What would become of them now that they knew the truth?
Enadil Moonweaver is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28th December 2006, 06:59 PM   #2 (permalink)
resident pedantissimo
 
chrispenycate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 2,980
Blog Entries: 4
Re: Chapter three of legacy Rewrite.

[/quote][quote]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Enadil Moonweaver View Post
Chapter 3: The Mystery of the Symbols.

During the night, a small group came to Griffin air. They were travelers who had been in Ursatavia during the time
not "during the time". "At the time" or "during the magick ceremony"
Quote:
of the Magick Ceremony. With them was a young girl
semicolon
Quote:
she was among the few mages that
had been
Quote:
were chosen but she had left during the festival
comma; and I think "had not talked to"
Quote:
so she did not talk to the Magick tester.

Nigel had let them in and talked with them until the sun came up. Upon hearing the voices, Mia and the others got up from their rooms groggily.

“Uncle, care to introduce us to these people?” questioned Azerath.

The small child looked at Azerath with wide inquisitive eyes and spoke in Kalnabian.
“My name is Neyuki Sanpuku, sorry to wake you sir.”

Azerath stared at the girl when she mentioned her name, “Sanpuku? You’re a merchant’s daughter right? The one from the festival.”

Neyuki nodded, “That is correct sir.”

Mia grinned, “You have had fun at the festival. Especially since I heard your name called.”

Neyuki nodded again, “Yes, I was chosen to go to the Magick School, but my islands
island's
Quote:
leader wants me to go to the Crystal Spire Guild first.”

Arien asked aloud “Don’t you think it’s weird.
no period
Quote:
That both of the leaders said we had to go to the Crystal Spire Guild?”

Everyone in the room looked at each other. It was weird. Why had the young mages been chosen? Why did they have to go to the guild? It was as if the leaders knew more than they were sharing. Mia thought a bit and then ran to the room that her
"that she, Rose and Arien"
Quote:
, Rose and Arien were sharing.

Neyuki grew curious , “Where did that girl go off to?”

Azerath, “Oh, Mia? I think she went back to her room to get something. By the way, my name’s Azerath. The other two girls are Arien and Rose.”

Mia returned to the room carrying the Communication sphere that Adenydd had given her. Crossing the room, she put it on a table. Mia began to concentrate and said.

“I need to speak to Adenydd of Ursatavia.”

Slowly the sphere grew brighter as Adenydd’s face appeared upon it’s
no apostrophe (illogical, but "its" is the only possessive that doesn't take one)
Quote:
surface.

“Oh Mia,
no capital "W"
Quote:
What‘s wrong?” asked Adenydd.

“There is more than going to the guild
comma
Quote:
isn’t there
comma
Quote:
Ma’am.”

Sighing Adenydd replied, “I was hoping you wouldn’t figure it out until you got there.”
She bowed her head for a moment and then looked at them, “There is a Prophecy of the world falling to darkness.”

Mia nodded, “I know the prophecy you speak of.” She began to recite the prophecy;

“A world will fall to shadows
comma
Quote:
darkness and despair.
A golden maiden will suffocate from darkness’ touch.
Heroes from far and wide will be the light of hope.
Guided by loyalty and faith one will betray
semicolon
Quote:
will others remain true.
question mark
Quote:
They shall journey to the heart of the world and free the light from the dark.”

Adenydd nodded, “That is correct Mia. A few nights ago, I had a prophetic dream. It told me who the Heroes would be. The ones marked with the Elemental symbols of Mana.”

“You mean,
I don't think they think of themselves as sufficiently important to warrent a capital "U", yet
Quote:
Us?” inquired Mia.

“Yes I do. Please forgive me
semicolon
Quote:
I had no choice but to send you.”

“Why do you ask of
for?
Quote:
forgiveness Ma’am?” Mia was slightly puzzled.

“Because it may already be too late, but you have to try. You cannot just give up. Prophecy states that you will be the Heroes. All of us here in Ursatavia believe in you.”

With Adenydd’s words the Communication sphere’s picture faded.
"The sextet"?
Quote:
Sextet looked at each other in wonder. The mystery of the symbols had been revealed. What would become of them now that they knew the truth?
You thought you'd got away with it because I was away on holiday, didn't you?
chrispenycate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28th December 2006, 07:03 PM   #3 (permalink)
Maiden of Hallian
 
Enadil Moonweaver's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 71
Re: Chapter three of legacy Rewrite.

^_^ Actually I was hoping you'd post some corrections. ^_^ I'll correct chapter three and then rewrite chapter four.
Enadil Moonweaver is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28th December 2006, 08:28 PM   #4 (permalink)
So it goes, so it goes.
 
WriterDoug's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 149
Re: Chapter three of legacy Rewrite.

This could be more of an opinion than criticism, but this just doesn't really do anything for me.

What you have here in this chapter sounds almost like an abridged version to the introduction of any videogame I have ever played where a young hero/ine (or two, or three or four) is enlightened of a prophecy and must go out into the world. It is incredibly formulaic in that regard.

I certainly get "weirded out" when your characters are quick to recite the prophecy, almost as if they have been rehearsing from the script and know it is their cue to tell the reader about it. To me, they are reading more like actors trapped on a cardboard stage than characters set in a fantasy world.

There is a bright note to this. I know virtually nothing of your intentions with the story, its plot further on down the road, all the twists and turns you might wish take, etc so it may in fact end up being a truly kickass story, but I do not feel like it is starting off in the right direction. It just need something done to it so it does not start off like every other prophecy tale that we have heard.

Remember how important the beginning is. It may set the stage for everything you do from here on out, and this can include allowing your mind to grow, or forcing you into rigid and predictable patterns that are not easy to fix later in the process!

cheers,
WD
WriterDoug is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28th December 2006, 09:11 PM   #5 (permalink)
Maiden of Hallian
 
Enadil Moonweaver's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 71
Re: Chapter three of legacy Rewrite.

I guess i chould change it from mia knowing the prophecy to Mia having Adenydd explain it . **ponders** Always room for improvement.
Enadil Moonweaver is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Legacy Chapter one rewrite. Enadil Moonweaver Critiques 9 16th April 2009 04:45 AM
Legacy of the Eldric - revised chapter 1 (short) DavidB Critiques 7 18th December 2006 11:18 AM
Chapter 1 - Legacy of the Eldric DavidB Critiques 6 11th April 2006 06:24 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:16 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0 ©2008, Crawlability, Inc.