Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums - View Single Post - The World Of Harry Potter Vs. The Magical Land Of Narnia.

weaveworld · 11th April 2006, 01:08 PM

I prefer Harry Potter to Narnia, however I did enjoy the narnia books and movie (don't judge me).

I love the idea of Harry's world, the fact that he has the whole other life and it goes on around him even when he is back with us muggles.

This sounds silly but I feel more for Harry Potter than I do about Peter, Edmund, Lucy, Susan, maybe its because Harry doesn't have any parents and plus he really did not get the pick of the draw when it comes to his relations.

Narnia is a colourful world, but it is just not that real to me, for one thing, I don't go into many wardrobes (well just for clothes really and I would never wear fur)

I agree with everyone here, you can't put them against each other, they are both great in their own way.

Sinak-Rune-I liked Blade, Queen of the Dammed just worried me.

Lissa-I love LOTR, just for the Aragorn factor!

Great Post FantasyHeart!

11th April 2006, 01:08 PM	#5 (permalink)
weaveworld Rockin! Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: West Dunbartonshire Posts: 573	Re: The World Of Harry Potter Vs. The Magical Land Of Narnia. I prefer Harry Potter to Narnia, however I did enjoy the narnia books and movie (don't judge me). I love the idea of Harry's world, the fact that he has the whole other life and it goes on around him even when he is back with us muggles. This sounds silly but I feel more for Harry Potter than I do about Peter, Edmund, Lucy, Susan, maybe its because Harry doesn't have any parents and plus he really did not get the pick of the draw when it comes to his relations. Narnia is a colourful world, but it is just not that real to me, for one thing, I don't go into many wardrobes (well just for clothes really and I would never wear fur) I agree with everyone here, you can't put them against each other, they are both great in their own way. Sinak-Rune-I liked Blade, Queen of the Dammed just worried me. Lissa-I love LOTR, just for the Aragorn factor! Great Post FantasyHeart!