[the smiling weirwood]

Originally Posted by sawtooth

I also don't understand the "I hate Catelyn" and "Please don't hate Catelyn" threads. These seem to me to be nothing but expressions of personal preference, and, as such, cannot be resolved when differences of opinion emerge. One of the many things I appreciate about of GRRM's writing is that he provides a heavy dollop of reality in character creation, such that each character has both desirable and undesirable qualities.

AMEN!