Horcruxes. The remaining.

[Majimaune]

Ahh but everyone was saying he was the sixth horcrux when he wasn't so I win there I think.

[Dave]

I was right too! Na Na, Na Na Na!

And I also thought it was the scar itself, so not completely correct.

But since he was a Horcrux he should have died, I don't see how him wanting and expecting to die makes any difference. PadfootandProngs was the closest:

Originally Posted by PadfootandProngs731

That theory has appeared here and there, but let us not forget, to make a Horcrux you need a death, and Harry's death probally was supposed to be a Horcrux, and Lord Vlodemort did not know he would mark Harry as his equal, therefore the theory that Harry's scar is, in fact, a Horcrux is almost impossible.

So wate, let us think, is there in fact only 5 more Horcuxes out there because Harry's murder was reserved for a Horcrux, but that did not turn out according to plan, henceforth, Voldemort never achieved at making 6 Horcruxes.....??

and dont forget Voldemort used significant deaths to create horcruxes, so he was waiting for Harry's to make a Horcrux, because of the prophecy and all, therefore he wasnt anticipating the backfire of his spell, making Harry as his equal because he didnt hear the last half of the prophecy, so he wouldve made Lily's death a Horcrux because he thought he was gfoing to get Harry...

I merged the Horcrux threads.

[Majimaune]

Ahh yes I see but to me this will always be my thread....

[Dave]

You should never have written in big letters "Harry is not a Horcrux". That was just asking for trouble! You were spot on about the other Horcruxes (or is it Horcruxi) though.

[Majimaune]

Yeah but I still think he shouldn't be called a horcrux because aren't horcruxes /horcruxi intentional?

[orionsixwings]

Originally Posted by Majimaune

Yeah but I still think he shouldn't be called a horcrux because aren't horcruxes /horcruxi intentional?

Majimaune, the author has already spoken ... give it up! You lost this bit, no matter what you say... we were right. Just admit it and save your self the horror of being humiliated again.

[Majimaune]

I'm saving myself very well I thought. Although I have almost no case.

[F'Lessan Amused]

go, go, maji, go, go

[Mary Hoffman]

The plural would be Horcruces.

Mary

[F'Lessan Amused]

well dint she say it was horcrux both ways..singular and plural..same as sheep

[Joel007]

Hey F'Lessan, Is the quote under your name from Mrs Doubtfire?

Anyway, you could say that since the Scar / Horcrux was created in a unique way and was not intended as an actual horcrux (plus it affected Harry in some strange ways), then it might not be a horcrux but something new.

[F'Lessan Amused]

yes it is frm mrs doubtfire...

it wont be a horcrux but a HARcrux (combine harry and horcrux lol)

[Majimaune]

Yes thankyou it is not a horcrux but a Harcrux. I like it F'lessan...also welcome :P

[Leisha]

Yes, welcome! It's nice to see you posting.

[F'Lessan Amused]

thanks maji