Eragon

[Majimaune]

Originally Posted by Triceratops

This is too derivitive
He did not push the genre
This is not unique enough to compete in this genre field.
Rather cliche
This seemed too familiar and did not break any new ground.
I've seen this before in several variations.
You've really got to have something new to breakout.

(Gee, guess where one of these comments came from).

I think with those you have said what many of us have tried to. I can't guess though.