Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums - View Single Post

Charming Serpent · 13th December 2007, 10:41 AM

I have changed my mind. Catelyn, by far, is my least favorite character. I am not saying I do not understand her motives and such, but I am rereading the entire series and she just friggin sucks. Granted, we have hindsight and are not in her shoes at those moments, but some things are all her fault. She sent Ned south. Practically pleaded with him to even though he wished to refuse. She is a true bitch to Jon who grew up never doing or saying anything wrong to her. She lets Jaime go!!?? For her daughters??? We are talking about 2 girls over infamous Jaime Lannister??? Even though she thinks Arya might be dead so she is only getting one back?? Like another post said on what thread I can't remember, she has the gall to question Bolton about letting Theon go, the man who killed her children, after the nerve of letting Karstark die after he killed Lannisters for CATELYN letting the kingslayer go. I mean, i don't care how bad she wanted her girls. She complains how men act fools in a passage or something, but then she lets a proven general, deadly swordsman and heir to Casterly Rock etc etc .. go??? Kidnaps Tyrion and brings him to Vale where she lets her sis take hold of her captive? Psshh, lady of the vale or not, I would have been like I am Stark of Winterfell this and that til Lyssa shut the hell up.

Now as Stoneheart she doesn't seemed to have changed. I don't know how being kinda undead makes you think, but why the hell is she going to hate/hang Brienne? What, cuz she didn't get her daughters back and speaks of Jaime?? Pffft, I was so glad she died in the Red Wedding, like seriously broke a smile when I read that part and now that biotch once again returns to piss me off. I hope she dies again with a twist of irony; like Nymeria savaging her or one of her kids.

I am vexed. Terribly vexed.

13th December 2007, 10:41 AM	#80 (permalink)
Charming Serpent Its ok to eat the apple. Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 326	Re: Least Favorite Character I have changed my mind. Catelyn, by far, is my least favorite character. I am not saying I do not understand her motives and such, but I am rereading the entire series and she just friggin sucks. Granted, we have hindsight and are not in her shoes at those moments, but some things are all her fault. She sent Ned south. Practically pleaded with him to even though he wished to refuse. She is a true bitch to Jon who grew up never doing or saying anything wrong to her. She lets Jaime go!!?? For her daughters??? We are talking about 2 girls over infamous Jaime Lannister??? Even though she thinks Arya might be dead so she is only getting one back?? Like another post said on what thread I can't remember, she has the gall to question Bolton about letting Theon go, the man who killed her children, after the nerve of letting Karstark die after he killed Lannisters for CATELYN letting the kingslayer go. I mean, i don't care how bad she wanted her girls. She complains how men act fools in a passage or something, but then she lets a proven general, deadly swordsman and heir to Casterly Rock etc etc .. go??? Kidnaps Tyrion and brings him to Vale where she lets her sis take hold of her captive? Psshh, lady of the vale or not, I would have been like I am Stark of Winterfell this and that til Lyssa shut the hell up. Now as Stoneheart she doesn't seemed to have changed. I don't know how being kinda undead makes you think, but why the hell is she going to hate/hang Brienne? What, cuz she didn't get her daughters back and speaks of Jaime?? Pffft, I was so glad she died in the Red Wedding, like seriously broke a smile when I read that part and now that biotch once again returns to piss me off. I hope she dies again with a twist of irony; like Nymeria savaging her or one of her kids. I am vexed. Terribly vexed.