View Single Post
Old 12th December 2007, 12:19 PM   #19 (permalink)
Kissmequick
loony
 
Kissmequick's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 320
Re: Film vs. Book: Battles

Quote:
they'd have had to have left Rivendell at least 10 days beforehand -
Apart from they came from Lorien?

I didn't like that they added the elves, but Peter Jackson said he wanted to make the them a little more involved. I thought the point was the elves were fading and not involving themselves.

I thought Helms deep wasnt't too bad. Although I can see why they did what they did with Eomer ( rather than add another character with Erkenbarnd) I missed him in the battle And too much gimmickry not enough 'have at you!' lol

Pelennor was a pretty awesome spectatcle ( odd how the rohirrim said they only had a few thousand men, yet when they turned up it looked more like twenty thousand lol) But the Legolas / Mumakil was too much.
Kissmequick is offline   Reply With Quote